Sponsored link
Thursday, March 28, 2024

Sponsored link

UncategorizedA new approach to public power: Just sell it

A new approach to public power: Just sell it

Scott Wiener wants to put the city in the retail electricity business
Scott Wiener wants to put the city in the retail electricity business

By Tim Redmond

JUNE 17, 2014 – At a time when Mayor Ed Lee is doing everything possible to shut down the city’s aspirations for public power, Supervisors Scott Wiener and London Breed are introducing legislation that could put San Francisco directly in the retail electricity business – at least, on a limited scale.

Wiener and Breed want to sell the city’s Hetch Hetchy hydropower directly to commercial customers – taking those customers away from Pacific Gas and Electric Co.

The two are introducing legislation today that would give the city’s Public Utilities Commission the right of first refusal to sell electricity, at retail rates, to any new development projects, including both business and residential, in San Francisco.

The idea, Wiener told me, is to get more customers for the city’s power enterprise, which badly needs new revenue to pay for maintenance and system upgrades. For example, the city has about 25,000 streetlights – and only $250,000 a year to maintain all of them.

Right now, Hetch Hetchy power goes to city departments and agencies; it powers Muni, the San Francisco Airport, and the lights at City Hall. All of the users get the power, generated at the city-owned hydropower project in the high Sierra — essentially at cost.

But there’s power left over most of the time, and that’s dumped at wholesale rates on the open market – part of a dubiously legal deal the city cut years ago with PG&E.

If this legislation is approved, the excess power could be sold at retail rates – comparable to what PG&E gets – to new office buildings and residences. The potential revenue is significant: If upcoming developments bought, say, 100 megawatts of power (not at all inconceivable given all the construction going on in the city) the SFPUC could net $40 million a year.

While Wiener wants much of that money to go for infrastructure improvements – which everyone agrees are needed – some could ultimately be used to fund other clean-power projects, which would generate more revenue for the city, which could fund further energy development.

Ultimately, the SFPUC could take on the role of a public-power agency, selling large amounts of retail power.

The project would demonstrate that the city is entirely capable of running a power system, and that it’s a lucrative venture – two critical arguments in pushing for a larger role for public power in San Francisco.

And it could add incentive for the mayor and the SFPUC to quit blocking CleanPowerSF, which might work nicely with this larger role for the city in selling its own carbon-free energy.

Given the strong support on the board for clean energy and public power, it’s likely Weiner will get enough votes for passage. He’ll probably get eight, enough to override a mayoral veto.

It’s hard to imagine how the mayor could oppose a deal that takes electricity we now dump for cheap and allow the city to sell it at market-rates. Except that this will take customers from PG&E, and put the city on a road that could lead to the private utility being replaced by a public agency.

Let’s see what kind of attack the company comes up with.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

Sponsored link

Featured

Screen Grabs: Fur flies in wrenching ‘The Fox’ and ridiculous ‘Dogman’

Cuddly canines comfort in Franz Streitberger’s World War II drama and kill in Luc Besson's new thriller.

SF prepares to evict people living in vehicles on Bernal Hill

After years of tolerance, parking enforcement set to start this week—but residents are already getting citations.

‘Dogman’ thriller’s stars dish on canine pasts—and strength of human connection

Luc Besson's latest features dozens of live pups, but Caleb Landry Jones and Jojo T. Gibbs were drawn to working with each other.

More by this author

Can SF get an independent study of toxic risk at Hunters Point?

Plus: Preserving history on the waterfront, and preserving the waterfront from sea-level rise. That's The Agenda for March 24-31

Hundreds rally for Preston kick-off

Spirited event seeks to draw a clear line between the billionaires and the rest of the city.

Some perspective on the case of a brutal stabbing of an Asian senior

The assailant is not going free; he faces a 10-year prison sentence if he doesn't enter a mandatory mental-health residential treatment program.
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED