Sponsored link
Friday, March 29, 2024

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsTech Office Creep comes to Chinatown

Tech Office Creep comes to Chinatown

Community leaders worry that neighborhood-serving businesses will be forced out by offices that violate local zoning laws

The second floor of this building is being used as office space, in violation of local zoning rules
The second floor of this building is being used as office space, in violation of local zoning rules

By Tim Redmond

APRIL 30, 2015 – The creep of illegal tech offices into neighborhood commercial districts, which we have been tracking in the Mission, has arrived in Chinatown.

At a press conference yesterday, members of the Chinatown Community Development Center and the Chinese Progressive Association pointed to a building at 950 Grant – where restaurant space has been converted to offices.

The zoning laws don’t allow general office use in the area.

Among the tenants of the new office space is the tech company Whil, which offers “a digital training platform for mindfulness and Yoga.”

But Gen Fujioka, the policy director for CCDC, told reporters that since 1986, central Chinatown has banned this sort of commercial office use. The Chinatown Area Plan, he said, “was created to protect Chinatown from office encroachment.”

Cindy Wu and Gen Fujioka talk about the danger of tech-office creep
Cindy Wu and Gen Fujioka talk about the danger of tech-office creep

The high rents that can be charged for tech offices drive out community-serving small businesses, he noted.

Cindy Wu, a community planner at CCDC who also sits on the San Francisco Planning Commission, said that the Planning Department is going to issue an enforcement notice mandating the removal of the office use.

She and Fujioka said they’re worried that this could be the start of a dangerous trend – as building in Chinatown become vacant, landlords are going to be looking for tenants who can pay the highest possible rent – and right now, that’s tech offices.

In fact, J.K. Dineen, the Chron’s commercial real-estate reporter, asked if community leaders were worried about the Empress of China building – which, he said, had been advertised as potential office space.

“That,” said Fujioka, “would be a very dangerous precedent.”

Wu said that landlords might be misleading tenants by telling them that the space was available for office use – and in fact, the woman who runs the office at 950 Grant, Jenny Chan, joined the press event to tell reporters that she had no idea that her business was in violation of zoning laws.

The landlord, she said, “told me it was commercial space.”

Jenny Chan, who has the office lease, came out to speak to the press
Jenny Chan, who has the office lease, came out to speak to the press

Chan operates a company called 1920C, which she told me is a “coworking space” that rents out desks by the hour, day, week, and month. She said that some of the tenants are nonprofits.

She posted a blog yesterday responding to the press conference, saying “we operate in a mixed-use development space with families living in the residential space upstairs and retail on the bottom.”

However, a Nov. 20, 2012 building permit issued for renovation work on the space states clearly that the city mandates “two retail units per floor, none over 2,500 square feet.”

The building owner did not return emails seeking comment.

Wu said this was the first example she’d seen of tech-office creep in Chinatown, and she’s convinced that the planners will respond – and she wants to see that happen anywhere there are illegal offices.

“The Planning Department should take on these cases immediately,” she said

Among the problems with these underground conversions: Office space typically attracts far more employees per square foot than retail or restaurants. That means more demand for Muni and housing.

Office developers have to pay fees to the city to offset those costs – and developers who convert other types of space to office use are liable for those fees.

But if the conversions happen without permits and in defiance of neighborhood zoning, then the city loses money.

It’s not as if the landlord – listed on the building permit as JQ Properties LP – can’t find tenants, Fujioka said: The vacancy rate in Chinatown is below five percent, and there are lots of community-serving business looking for space.

But those businesses can’t pay as much rent as offices can. Chan said as much to me when she told me that the only way she could afford the rent on the place was to bring in tech companies.

I feel bad for her if, in fact, she was misled into thinking the space was legal for offices. “Landlords,” Wu said, “need to understand the Planning Code.”

Zoning exists for a lot of reasons, but one of them is to keep property values at a level that community-based businesses can afford. And while the City Planning Department’s enforcement division is overwhelmed right now with Airbnb issues, you’d think that the city could at least make sure that flagrant, obvious violations are addressed – so that other landlords don’t think they can follow the modern tech model of doing whatever the hell they want, and asking for permission later.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

Sponsored link

Featured

Bilal Mahmood puffed up his resume—and the Chron doesn’t seem to care

Neuroscientists say he's not a 'neuroscientist' (he's not an 'economist,' either)—but the dailies still let his claims stand without challenge.

102-year-old heroine Betty Reid Soskin’s journey premieres on Bay Area stage

Writings and songs by the nation's oldest park ranger and longtime activist form base of 'Sign My Name To Freedom.'

With Castro Theatre out, massive Frameline LGBTQ+ film fest gets creative

New executive director Allegra Madsen takes on fresh challenges with an agile attitude—and innovative locations.

More by this author

In mayoral race preview, supes reject Breed veto of Peskin zoning bill

Mayor's move was all politics, not policy, most board members agree.

Can SF get an independent study of toxic risk at Hunters Point?

Plus: Preserving history on the waterfront, and preserving the waterfront from sea-level rise. That's The Agenda for March 24-31

Hundreds rally for Preston kick-off

Spirited event seeks to draw a clear line between the billionaires and the rest of the city.
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED