Sponsored link
Sunday, January 23, 2022

Sponsored link

ElectionsCampaign TrailRecall Boudin ad appears to violate state election law

Recall Boudin ad appears to violate state election law

Andrea Shorter is quoted in the ad; she's also paid by the campaign. State law says that has to be disclosed.

-

The six-figure video ad promoting the recall of District Attorney Chesa Boudin appears to violate state law.

The ad, as sfist points out, features Andrea Shorter, who is a paid staffer for the recall effort, as well as Mary Jung, who is the campaign treasurer.

Andrea Shorter is paid by the campaign, but the ad doesn’t say that.

State law requires that campaign ads disclose if anyone featured in the ad is getting paid for their work. The language is pretty clear:

An advertisement paid for by a committee described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall include a disclosure statement stating “(spokesperson’s name) is being paid by this campaign or its donors” in highly visible font shown continuously if the advertisement consists of printed or televised material, or spoken in a clearly audible format if the advertisement is a radio broadcast or telephonic message.  If the advertisement is a television or video advertisement, the statement shall be shown continuously, except when the disclosure statement required by Section 84504.1 is being shown.

There is nothing in the ad that discloses that Shorter is paid $16,000 a month by the recall campaign.

The law allies to ballot measures, and under a longtime FPPC determination, recalls count as ballot measures. That’s why there are no campaign-contribution limits.

This is just part of the ongoing scam that is the pro-recall campaign. The people who are out front are either paid or unpaid staffers or people who left the District Attorney’s Office when Boudin was elected.

I called the recall campaign office and asked for comment. I also asked to speak to Jung. I was told someone would call me back. Nobody ever did.

The problem with this sort of ad campaign is that the Fair Political Practices Commission and the SF Ethics Commission will, maybe, investigate, and maybe, months from now, announce a fine, that will mean nothing to a campaign with gobs of right-wing and Republican money.

The law doesn’t allow the regulators to shut down the ad. It doesn’t force them to admit that the ad was misleading. And the investigations take so long that the election may be over by the time anything happens.

So campaign are free to cheat and foul. With impunity.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link

Top reads

Developer money to Haney may violate SF’s ethics rules

Three builders with projects pending or just approved in SF donated to a sitting supervisor.

What the big money behind the School Board recall means

The very rich who are pouring more than $1 million into getting rid of three board members have an agenda that goes far beyond the San Francisco schools.

Opinion: Are we losing the Castro Theatre?

New management Another Planet Entertainment wants to "explode" the neighborhood with music and entertainment. But what about good old films and LGBTQ events?

More by this author

Developer money to Haney may violate SF’s ethics rules

Three builders with projects pending or just approved in SF donated to a sitting supervisor.

What the big money behind the School Board recall means

The very rich who are pouring more than $1 million into getting rid of three board members have an agenda that goes far beyond the San Francisco schools.

How Recology’s monopoly leads to very dubious rate accounting

City records show the way the garbage company could be inflating its costs—and charging consumers for it.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED