Sponsored link
Tuesday, April 1, 2025

Sponsored link

City HallThe AgendaIt's fine to recall progressives, but not a conservative supervisor? Ask the...

It’s fine to recall progressives, but not a conservative supervisor? Ask the Chron

Plus: Who will be the next board president—and what will Breed say at her final Question Time? That's The Agenda for Dec. 15-22

-

I read with interest Joe Eskenazi’s analysis of the potential recall of Sup. Joel Engardio: Recalls, he suggests, are generally a bad idea—but in this case, Engardio built his political career supporting … recalls, of the district attorney and the School Board.

Now the Chron (or its affiliate, SFGATE) is running pieces saying the recall is undemocratic—this from a news operation that endlessly fanned the flames for the Chesa Boudin and School Board recalls.

Joel Engardio got elected after promoting recalls. Now he’s facing his own. Campaign photo.

I don’t know if enough District 4 residents, who are overwhelmingly furious at Engardio’s support for Proposition K and closing the Great Highway, will sign a recall petition. If they do, the real question becomes: Where do the billionaire astroturf groups and the big donors go? Will the oligarchs who want to take over the city side with a politician who has done everything they could ever ask? Will Mayor Daniel Lurie, who would get to appoint his own ally to that seat if Engardio is recalled, weigh in on the race?

Remember, as the Phoenix Project notes, many of the oligarchs were big donors to Prop. K.

Does the “moderate” power structure close ranks to protect one of their own—and if so, does that undermine the ability of the billionaires to control votes on the West Side?

Is it just fine to recall progressives, but not conservatives?

City Hall is about to shut down for the holidays, but that doesn’t stop the politics—and right now, one of the key points of discussion is the next president of the Board of Supes.

It’s a board with four solid progressives, including newly elected Sups. Jackie Fielder and Chyanne Chen, along with Sup. Connie Chan, just re-elected, and Sup. Shamann Walton; four solid conservatives, including newly elected Danny Sauter and Bilal Mahmood, along with Sups. Joel Engardio and Matt Dorsey—and two in the middle, Sups. Myrna Melgar and Rafael Mandelman, both of whom want the job.

At this point, nobody has six votes.

The only way a new board president wins with no progressive support is if all the mods and conservatives agree on a candidate—and with two of them running, hard, for the job, that’s not happening right now.

The final board meeting of the year, and the last meeting for Sups. Hillary Ronen, Aaron Peskin, Ahsha Safai, and Dean Preston is Tuesday/17. As is traditional, the board will celebrate their work and service. It’s also the last time Mayor London Breed will be on hand for Question Time; nobody put forward any questions, so the mayor gets to talk for five minutes. I wonder what message she will use in her last chance to address a board that he has so often clashed with and sometimes openly disdained.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link

Featured

Drama Masks: Hypnotic maritime flamenco, messages in a bottle

Dance tells a yarn in 'Songs from a Sinking Ship.' Plus: How did the city's stages acknowledge Trans Day of Visibility?

Is the new Berkeley mayor really a conciliatory outsider?

Her history as president of the League of Women Voters suggests otherwise

PHOTOS: Families march on Newsom’s house for trans rights

On Trans Day of Visibility, more than 100 parents and kids descended on the governor's Kentfield residence—and then danced to 'Pink Pony Club.'

More by this author

Note to Matt Dorsey: UCSF doctors support harm reduction

Plus: SFPD still seems to have problems with illegal searches. That's The Agenda for March 31-April 6

New study by Fed economists directly contradicts Yimby narrative on housing prices

Dramatic data suggests gentrification and income inequality are far more important than 'constraints' on development as the cause of high housing prices

Another War on Drugs measure passes, with only two dissenting votes

Fielder and Chan oppose plan that has serious flaws and could lead to more deaths. 9-2 votes are becoming a pattern.
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED