Sponsored link
Thursday, November 19, 2026

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsPoliceFielder wants info on high-speed chase that led to crash injuring six...

Fielder wants info on high-speed chase that led to crash injuring six in the Mission

Supes letter of inquiry raises questions about the new policy of allowing cops to chase suspects who are not an immediate violent threat

-

Sup. Jackie Fielder is asking the Police Department to explain how the high-speech chase that lead to a crash injuring six in the Mission took place—and whether the officers followed the rules.

Sup. Jackie Fielder, shown here at a campaign rally with former Sups. Dean Preston and Tom Ammiano, is trying to hold the cops accountable.

In a Feb. 11 letter of inquiry, Fielder asked Chief Bill Scott to tell the supes:

What were the circumstances surrounding this case? a. Please share the top speed of the police car or cars that were involved in the accident. 2. What is the existing SFPD policy regarding police chases and how have officers been trained on it? 3. How did this incident comply with current SFPD policy, and how did it rise to the level of vehicle pursuit that ultimately put many lives in danger?

What is the SFPD protocol after a car chase that leads to injuries or fatalities? a. What data is collected and reported after a police chase occurs, when someone is killed during a police chase, or when someone is injured? 5. Who made the judgement call to engage in a police chase, and based on what factors? 6. Were there other options, such as drones, or other measures that could have been deployed to avoid a vehicle pursuit that puts lives in danger? 7. And lastly, what accountability mechanisms are in place for officers whose decisions injure innocent bystanders and extensively damage local businesses?

The crash, and her letter, raise the issue of how the cops are using their new authority, granted by a ballot measure sponsored by former Mayor London Breed, to engage in vehicle pursuits like this one.

In the past, the city limited high-speed chases through residential areas unless the occupants of the vehicle were armed and considered an immediate threat to the public.

So far, the SFPD has not released any information suggesting that was the case here. MissionLocal reports that the suspects were involved in organized retail theft.

Prior to Prop. E, which passed last March, that would not have allowed officers to race through the streets, in this case leading so serious injuries and the destruction of a parklet owned by a local small business.

But Breed, in a desperate attempt to seem even more pro-cop than her opponents, put a measure on the ballot that undermined her own Police Commission. The Bay Guardian noted:

Specifically, the measure would allow more high-speed chases (yes, on the narrow streets of SF, where they frequently lead to injuries and sometimes deaths); give the cops far more authority to spy on San Franciscans without oversight (including with drones); and reduce the reporting requirements for use of force incidents (which provides the data showing the radical racial disparities in use of force).

We are now seeing the results.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. 

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Featured

Drama Masks: In spooky ‘Covenant,’ a Black Southern Gothic tale channels the blues

Berkeley Rep's riff on the legend of Robert Johnson and the Devil takes a woman's perspective, and pours on the chills.

The luminous helices of Philip Glass: 90-year-old composer celebrated with etude marathon

Cal Performances marks minimalist master's upcoming birthday with star-studded performance of piano works.

A rocky road for ‘I Play Rocky’: ‘At one point I thought, screw this,’ says director

Peter Farrelly's meta-take on Sylvester Stallone's classic had to surmount major obstacles—just like its subject.

More by this author

A 2006 court decision seems to make clear that Prop. A ended lifetime term limits for supes

Prop. A contained a mistake. It would allow Aaron Peskin to run for supe again, the courts have ruled.

Can SF handle any new data centers?

Plus: Limiting robot checkout, preventing nuisance evictions .... and does the Chron really think hotel workers are 'selfish?' That's The Agenda for Nov. 16-23

Marina Safeway lawsuit will be a key test of the Wiener-Yimby agenda

Can a project with serious toxics issues get fast-track approval with no environmental review? The City Planning Dept. thinks so.
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED