Sponsored link
Wednesday, September 17, 2025

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsPoliceFull board will hear Lurie's attempt to fire pro-reform police commissioner

Full board will hear Lurie’s attempt to fire pro-reform police commissioner

Mandelman calls for Committee of the Whole to consider whether to allow the mayor to oust Max Carter Oberstone

-

Max Carter Oberstone, the lawyer and Police Commission member Mayor Lurie wants to fire, will get his day in court, so to speak, on Feb. 25, when the Board of Supes will hold a Committee of the Whole meeting to consider the mayor’s request.

That will give Carter Oberstone, who has been among the best members of the commission, a change to challenge Lurie’s effort to oust him in the middle of a term that doesn’t end until 2026.

Max Carter Oberstone has been an independent member of the Police Commission. That’s why Lurie wants him gone.

Under the City Charter, the mayor can’t remove an appointed police commissioner without the consent of a majority of the supes.

Typically a request like this would go to the board’s Rules Committee for a hearing, then on to the full board for a vote.

But Board President Rafael Mandelman told me that several of the other supes have requested that the full board hear the case. “So I am calling a Committee of the Whole,” he told me.

That hearing will take place Feb. 25.

Mandelman said he expects Carter Oberstone will be present to oppose the move, and that he hopes a representative of the Mayor’s Office will also be present. Carter Oberstone told me he will definitely be there.

All of the supes will have a chance to ask questions, and the public will have an opportunity to comment.

Given the prominent role Carter Oberstone has played in police reform and accountability, and his willingness to stand up to the previous mayor, it’s likely a good number of community advocates will be on hand, and may be contacting supervisors in the meantime.

This will, on the other hand, be a key vote for Lurie, so his office will also be putting pressure on the supes. Right now, it appears the mayor has the votes to oust Carter Oberstone.

But as any judge or defense lawyer will say, you never know with a jury.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Featured

Voters recall Engardio, by huge margin

Now it's up to Lurie to appoint a D4 supe—and it won't be an easy choice

Screen Grabs: Psychedelic bro love swirls in ‘Lemurian Candidate’

Plus: Studio 8 Film Festival celebrates work from dearly departed Art Institute, Cheryl Dunye at BAMPFA, more releases.

Best of the Bay 2025 Editors’ Pick: Dani Offline

No wonder she's been featured at Noise Pop—this nouveau hip-hop vibe merchant isn't faking a thing.

More by this author

Voters recall Engardio, by huge margin

Now it's up to Lurie to appoint a D4 supe—and it won't be an easy choice

We will probably know Tuesday evening if Sup. Joel Engardio keeps his seat

Early results could tell the tale—and if the D4 supe is out, what will Lurie do?

Strange (and maybe inappropriate) actions at the Planning Commission …

... plus an attack on preservation in North Beach, and has the privatized zoo improved enough to get another $3 million? That's The Agenda for Sept. 14 to 21
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED