Wednesday, July 8, 2026

News + PoliticsPG&E has no friends at a Planning Commission hearing

PG&E has no friends at a Planning Commission hearing

Report on public power system has unanimous support: 'A glorious thought.'

-

The Planning Commission hearing today on the Draft Environmental Impact Report for municipalizing PG&E was remarkable for what it didn’t include: Any opposition.

The commissioners don’t always agree on everything, and members of the public who show up to comment often disagree with the panel and with each other.

The company is running out of allies—and time

In the past, PG&E has always been able to drum up some level of support, with from its union, the IBEW, or from some sort of astroturf coalition.

Not today.

Every single person who spoke about the DEIR said the city should move forward as quickly as possible to kick out the private utility and bring the distribution system under public control.

Byron Kaufman, an energy consultant and the founder of GridScience.AI, discussed the need for an abundant clean-energy future, and said “this will only happen if you take full control.” Commissioner Kathrin Moore said “I am in full support of finding an alternative” to PG&E. Sean McGarry, who is an appointee of former Mayor London Breed is often a more conservative voice on the panel, said that “our ability to get free of PG&E is a glorious thought.”

The message: PG&E doesn’t have a lot of allies at City Hall any more. Now it’s just a matter of time.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Featured

Public bank moves forward

Supes, 9-2, put measure before the voters. What is up with Sup. Alan Wong?

What happened to SF’s privacy culture?

In just a few years, this city has moved from a leader in surveillance guardrails to a place where we are spied on everywhere, even in gay bars

Sculptor Stephanie Robison’s tactile wonders call out ‘squeeze me’

Provocatively melding stone and soft materials into playful polymorphs, the Oakland artist hopes to spark 'the ability to think differently'

More by this author

Public bank moves forward

Supes, 9-2, put measure before the voters. What is up with Sup. Alan Wong?

In a surreal hearing, supes move to cut affordable housing requirements

Plus: A key vote on public power at a diminished Planning Commission, and a dramatic change to 'housing first' policy ... That's The Agenda for July 5-12

Why are socialists winning in NYC—but not in ‘progressive’ SF?

We may not have a Mamdani—yet—but there are hints of change in recent political developments.

You might also likeRELATED