I Play Rocky (now playing in Bay Area theaters) and the story behind it are a little bit like those nested Russian dolls.
First, there is Rocky, the 1976 Best Picture Oscar winner that launched Sylvester Stallone into the stratosphere as an actor and screenwriter and spawned five sequels as well as Ryan Coogler’s Creed trilogy. Then there is Peter Gamble’s screenplay of I Play Rocky, which teases out the parallels between Rocky and the behind-the-scenes story of the film.
Then there is the making of I Play Rocky, in which Gamble and star Anthony Ippolito take inspiration from Stallone’s gambit and create their own opportunities. And as with the making of Rocky, I Play Rocky faced turbulent headwinds during the race to completion, so much so that director Peter Farrelly entertained pulling the plug on the movie.
“There were many times this thing almost fell apart,” Farrelly says during a visit to the Bay Area where I Play Rocky was the Mill Valley Film Festival’s Centerpiece presentation. “It was to the point where the bond company—we didn’t get all the money from Amazon—in pre-production told me they were going to close it down. They were not convinced we could do it.
“And at one point, I was thinking, ‘Screw this, I’m going home. This is this is too stressful. Except I remembered Anthony working out for a year, and Peter Gamble, it was his big break. And I thought, ‘Okay, we’re gonna keep going.’ But there was one moment I remember just if they weren’t involved, if I didn’t have Anthony and Peter Gamble hadn’t written this amazing script, I would have just said to hell with it.”
But such is the power of Rocky. The 27-year-old Ippolito wasn’t even born when the first five movies came out but he remembers seeing the sixth, Rocky Balboa (2006), in a theater when he was seven years old, getting as close to the screen as he could.
Farrelly himself was an 18-year-old accounting major when Rocky came out. The man, whose own work spans ribald comedies like There’s Something About Mary to Best Picture winner Green Book, recalls being blown away by what Stallone and director John G. Avildsen achieved. Rocky was moving and uplifting. The future filmmaker thought it was incredible.
“It started a whole genre,” he avers. “There’s no Rudy without this. No Hoosiers. You know, all those underdog stories.”
Add I Play Rocky to those underdog stories. Gamble knocked around the film business for 20 years without breaking through before a suggestion from his manager led him to explore the idea of a Stallone biopic. But what stood out to the screenwriter was not the breadth of his long career but the spark that ignited it. A journeyman actor who endured homelessness and once made ends meet by appearing in softcore porn, Stallone made his own luck when he not only wrote Rocky but insisted on playing the part, stubbornness that nearly sabotaged the project.
Gamble seized on the similarities between underdog boxer Rocky Balboa and his creator.
The screenplay found its way to producer Toby Emmerich, who first worked with Farrelly in 1994 when Emmerich was a music executive on Farrelly’s feature debut Dumb and Dumber. He passed it along to the director. Who added it to the pile of scripts that he would look at—eventually. But his daughter Apple’s then-boyfriend spotted it and asked if he could read it and came back, enthusing that it was “one of the best movies ever made.”
“I was like, ‘What a moron! This kid’s probably never read a script. It’s got a beginning, a middle, and an end, and he thinks it’s a masterpiece,’” laughs Farrelly. “But because he said that, I thought, ‘I’m gonna read 10 pages.’ Started reading it. Couldn’t put it down. It’s the best script I ever read.
“I told the guy, ‘You could read a thousand screenplays before you would come across one this good. You have no idea how good this thing is.’ And he said, ‘Yeah, I did. I told you it’s like the best movie of all time.’ But yeah, the reason I almost didn’t read it is because I thought I knew everything about Rocky. And I didn’t.”

As Farrelly commenced with pre-production, Ippolito read an article about the movie in the works. Like Stallone 50 years ago, the actor was looking for his big break. He started working as a child and up until now, his largest role was that of Al Pacino in the 2022 miniseries The Offer. He admits that he was not the most likely candidate to play Stallone.
“I was more similar to kind of Pacino’s stature, and Bob Evans has a line in ‘The Offer’ where he’s like, ‘I’m not letting a shrimp play Michael,’ Ippolito says.
But the actor’s size, which he would later alter by spending a year at the gym and packing on 40 pounds of muscle, did not dissuade him. He was a fan of Farrelly’s and of what he knew about Stallone’s story. He was determined to be considered for the role.
“I made this audition in my grandmother’s basement, where I was didn’t have the script, but I still tried to capture some of the physicality to just send them something that showed them I was enthusiastic about the idea.” Ippolito says. “And then after that, when I got my hands on the script, I put more stuff on.”

The original plan was to conduct a worldwide search to find the perfect Stallone, but Ippolito’s homemade tapes found their way to casting director Rick Montgomery, who called Farrelly: “We got the guy.” Farrelly never looked at another actor.
There are two parts to Ippolito’s performance. He is Sylvester Stallone, a writer and performer bursting with unstoppable ambition. But in scenes replicating Rocky, many shot in the movie’s original locations in Philadelphia, he is also Rocky Balboa, never-say-die fighter. It was important to both actor and director to maintain that distinction.
“The genius of Anthony’s performance is Stallone and Rocky are not the same people, and he knew that,” Farrelly says. “He recognized Rocky as a certain character. And he went down a rabbit hole, looking at Stallone interviews, looking at Stallone’s other performances and TV shows, and that’s the subtle difference.
”I feel just blessed because so many things had to go right,” he adds. “First of all, starting with Peter Gamble’s script, the masterpiece, and then if you don’t get this guy, you know you could have that exact same script with a different actor, and we’re not sitting here. It’s just a different movie, and I mean everything about it. Just the fact that like he’s a lefty, and you know Rocky was a lefty, left-handed boxer.
“If you don’t have him, there’s a million things fall that fall into your lap that have to that all have to work out.”
I PLAY ROCKY is now playing in Bay Area theaters.





