Sponsored link
Sunday, November 22, 2026

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsCrimePublic defender has the right to refuse cases, Appeals Court is told

Public defender has the right to refuse cases, Appeals Court is told

Lawyers for Mano Raju say an overworked staff can't handle every case the DA pursues.

-

Lawyers for Public Defender Mano Raju argued in the Court of Appeal Friday that Raju should not be held in contempt and fined for refusing to accept cases that his overburdened staff can’t handle.

Much of the argument rested on legal technicalities: If a public defender says they don’t have the capacity to handle a case, and thus has a conflict, can the court demand to know why?

At that point, can the court order the public defender to take a case anyway, and what’s the standard of evidence that the court has to hear and present?

PD Mano Raju was held in contempt and fined because he refuses to take cases a tough-on-crime DA pursues when he doesn’t have the staff to handle the load

Justice Gordon Burns asked, “Can the court explore why you are not available?”

Kory DeClark, representing Raju, said that “the first step is deference,” that is, if the lawyer says they can’t take a case, the court needs to respect that. “The public defender is in a better situation to make that call.”

The three-judge panel was dubious—but was also dubious about the Superior Court’s position that Judge Harry Dorfrman had the right to force Raju to take cases that would violate a defendant’s constitutional right to effective legal counsel.

Burns: “How can you appoint counsel when counsel isn’t ready to proceed?”

Both sides also discussed whether Dorfman had done a fair job examining the facts before making his ruling.

But the larger issue here isn’t about technicalities in statutes or case law. It’s simple: If the mayor and the district attorney want to get “tough on crime,” and arrest more people and fill the jails, do they have a responsibility to give the Public Defender’s Office enough money to handle all of those cases?

If not, doesn’t Raju have the right to say that he can’t provide effective counsel, and force the court to hire outside counsel—which costs the city more than it would pay to hire enough public defenders?

The case has state and national implications. The more cities and states and the federal government try to deal with social problems and immigration as criminal issues, the more it’s going to cost not just to staff the jails but to be sure that every defendant has adequate counsel.

That’s the side of the “tough on crime” agenda that none of the politicians want to talk about. Mass arrests are expensive—not just for the cops and the prosecutors, who never seem to have any problem getting their budgets approved, but for the defense.

If the Appeals Court rules for Raju, Mayor Daniel Lurie and the Board of Supes are going to have to face reality: You can’t just hire more cops and give the DA more money to haul more people off to jail. You also have to come up with the funding for their defense.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. 

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Featured

For ‘Misty Green,’ British actor Rosalind Eleazar went walking in LA

Filming Chris Rock's show business fable alongside Daniel Kaluuya was an immersion in Hollywood life—and survival.

Local protesters gather to oppose Trump-Philippines tech deal

Pax Silica, an administration move to develop data centers and chipmaking in the Philippines, sours outrage in Manila—and SF

Ethics complaint raises questions about Lurie and APE

Did the entertainment company donate money to Lurie when he was approving a contract for more concerts in Golden Gate Park?

More by this author

A 2006 court decision seems to make clear that Prop. A ended lifetime term limits for supes

Prop. A contained a mistake. It would allow Aaron Peskin to run for supe again, the courts have ruled.

Can SF handle any new data centers?

Plus: Limiting robot checkout, preventing nuisance evictions .... and does the Chron really think hotel workers are 'selfish?' That's The Agenda for Nov. 16-23

Marina Safeway lawsuit will be a key test of the Wiener-Yimby agenda

Can a project with serious toxics issues get fast-track approval with no environmental review? The City Planning Dept. thinks so.
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED