Sponsored link
Friday, February 7, 2025

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsPolicePublic outrage works: Killer robots are dead, at least for the moment

Public outrage works: Killer robots are dead, at least for the moment

After massive organizing efforts, supes back off on lethal force issue—but that discussion is by no means over.

-

Sometimes, organized public outcry works, particularly in a city with district elections of supervisors, where the public officials making the decision have to be closer to the people who have input.

So this afternoon, after a bit pf parliamentary confusion, the supes voted 8-3 to ban the immediate use of killer robots, and sent the issue back to committee for more discussion.

Only Sups. Rafael Mandelman, Matt Dorsey, and Catherine Stefani voted to keep the previous policy, which would have allowed the cops to arm robots with bombs to blow up human beings.

Those three supes said they were convinced that the debate was over, and everything that could be said had been said, and the cops should have the right to deploy those weapons if they’re needed.

But over the past week, since the first vote in favor of the killer robots, this has become a national issue, with reporters from news outlets around the country apparently stunned that such a progressive city would allow this.

And a huge public outcry put the supes under close scrutiny, as 44 community and civil-rights groups demanded that the policy change.

Sup. Aaron Peskin, who had helped negotiation the weapons policy over several public hearings, and who had voted in favor of the robots last week, took the lead in moving to ban lethal force by robots and send the issue back to the Rules Committee.

It took a while. The situation was unusual: The supes had approved the killer robots last week, 8-3, but every ordinance requires a second vote. And in this case, Peskin wanted to send the rest of the police weapons policy, which has a lot of other issues, forward for final approval, with the robot section removed.

After a lengthy discussion on how that could happen, and a series of votes, the board managed to approve the weapons policy without the robots, specifically ban lethal force by robots, and send that part of the policy back for more discussion.

Which is badly needed. The role of robots in law enforcement is going to become a serious national debate in the next few years, as software developers create AI programs that could allow robots to do threat analysis, and potentially even decide when lethal force is acceptable.

At least for the moment, San Francisco is proceeding with caution.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. 

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link

Featured

Full board will hear Lurie’s attempt to fire pro-reform police commissioner

Mandelman calls for Committee of the Whole to consider whether to allow the mayor to oust Max Carter Oberstone

Drama Masks: Voices of incarcerated women take center stage at YBCA

Art exhibit 'The Only Door I Can Open' and Flyaway Productions' 'I Give You My Sorrows' speak out for prisoners' rights.

Inside the pervasive news media bias in the Berkeley mayoral election

Missing context, misleading stories helped boost longshot Adena Ishii into the city's top office.

More by this author

Full board will hear Lurie’s attempt to fire pro-reform police commissioner

Mandelman calls for Committee of the Whole to consider whether to allow the mayor to oust Max Carter Oberstone

Lurie is trying to fire an independent police commissioner; maybe the chief is next

Mayor wants the supes to let him remove Max Carter-Oberstone, one of the best members of the oversight panel, for no good reason except power

A very rich guy says low taxes on the very rich are bad for everyone, even the very rich

Morris Pearl, president of Patriotic Millionaires, talks about what's really wrong with the tax system—and whether it can change in the Trump era.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED