Sponsored link
Sunday, November 15, 2026

Sponsored link

City HallThe AgendaCan SF handle any new data centers?

Can SF handle any new data centers?

Plus: Limiting robot checkout, preventing nuisance evictions .... and does the Chron really think hotel workers are 'selfish?' That's The Agenda for Nov. 16-23

-

As far as we know, San Francisco has three data centers. Two are in Bayview, and one is in Soma. They’re relatively small in terms of energy and water use. The two associated places on Paul Avenue have been around for decades, since the days when we called them “server farms.”

The City Planning Department admits other centers may exist, on a smaller scale, since the department has no formal inventory of this type of land use.

The Board of Supes recently approved a 45-day moratorium on new centers, and the Land Use and Transportation Committee will consider Monday/16 a year-long extension. The Planning Department has done a study on the issue, and its findings suggests that the city needs at least a  moratorium, if not an outright ban.

Data Center on Paul Ave. City Planning photo.

From an environmental justice perspective, data centers are a public nuisance—and to no surprise, all are in low-income neighborhoods with high concentrations of people of color. I don’t think we’re going to see a data center in Pacific Heights.

The city also has a major capacity problem. According to the report, big data centers use as much as 50 megawatts of power, which is enough for 25,000 homes. The city’s under immense pressure to approve more housing—and the grid doesn’t have much space available.

The current capacity of the power lines coming into San Francisco is 1 gigawatt. Peak usage is about 900 megawatts, and that’s rising, as more residents, businesses, and vehicles are shifting to electric power. A 50 MW data center would overwhelm the grid.

PG&E can’t handle this load. Expanding the power lines coming into San Francisco could take at least eight years, and would cost hundreds of millions of dollars. If the city had a municipal utility, it could control new data centers:

The City of Santa Clara, which already has 55 existing data centers, has its own municipal utility (Silicon Valley Power, SVP) that stopped taking new applications for service from data centers (but not other development) in 2023 while it assessed the ability to provide power for these uses and while they await the completion of a major transmission expansion project expected to be completed in the next couple years.

Then there’s water. From the report:

SFPUC has concerns for existing and potential future data centers about the types of chemicals (and their concentrations and amounts) that are being used for cooling systems; whether wastewater discharges from data centers are within the local temperature limit of 125 °F; and whether the combined sewer system has the capacity to handle the data center’s wastewater flow, especially during wet weather. Depending on the water quality, there’s a risk of causing additional corrosion to sewers. SFPUC uses site-specific wastewater discharge permits to regulate non-domestic and temporary discharges into the City’s combined sewer system.

Mayor Daniel Lurie loves AI, and if the companies he sees as the city’s economic future want local data centers, I suspect he will by sympathetic. Of course, it we don’t build them here, we’re just outsourcing the problem to other communities.

The committee will consider the planning report Monday/16, and the full board will discuss a year-long moratorium Tuesday/17.

I don’t use self-checkout. I hate having to take pictures of checks on my phone and sending them to the bank. People used to get paid to do that work; now they’ve lost their jobs, and I’m supposed to do it, for no pay. It’s hard to find an open bank branch with real tellers these days, and sometimes it costs money to get a human on the phone for customer service.

When I have an internet outage, my provider’s phone system tells me to seek help on the web; dude, I can’t get to the web. That’s the problem.

Not everyone is young and tech-savvy. Some people need people, real people, to help them with their groceries or prescriptions or banking.

And the more technology replaces people, the more we are going to have to deal with massive unemployment.

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee will consider Thursday/19 a measure that would place limits on self-checkout facilities at grocery stores and pharmacies. The measure would require one employee-staffed checkout center for every three self-check centers, would limit self-check to 15 items, and would mandate one employee to supervise every self-check operations center.

The measure has six co-sponsors, enough to ensure it will pass, but not enough to override a mayoral veto. That hearing starts at 10am.

Thanks to the AI boom and radical economic inequality, evictions are soaring in San Francisco; landlords are looking for any possible loophole to get rid of rent-controlled tenants who are paying below market rate. One tactic: Cite a “nuisance.” Some landlords in Chinatown tried to use that tool to evict renters who hung their laundry out to dry on a clothesline. It’s been used to evict tenants who have bicycles in public spaces.

The Land Use and Transportation Committee will consider Monday/16 an ordinance that would restrict “nuisance” evictions. Among other things, it would ban evictions for damage to the property if the tenants paid to have the place repaired. That hearing starts at 10 am.

A final note: I’m not surprised that the Chron would allow the head of a hotel lobbying group to write an oped promoting the economic interests of the giants of the hospitality industry. I’m not even surprised by the doom-and-gloom rhetoric:

If this amendment were to pass, unions would be able to hold hotels and the city hostage, and San Francisco’s hospitality and reputational recovery would come to a screeching halt. The union and its representatives would be able to use the threat of a legal filing to gain leverage with hotels during contract negotiations. As a result, investments in new hotels and investments in renovations will dry up, and San Francisco will become a no-invest zone once again.

But this is still a union town, and language like this is a bit shocking:

Yet the full Board of Supervisors isn’t voting to update any of the health and safety aspects of the ordinance. Instead, it would just add a legal loophole for unions to leverage to further their selfish interests

“Selfish interests?” The hotel workers, who are barely getting by while the big hotels are earning billion-dollar profits? “Selfish interests” of hotel worker unions facing a Lurie Administration that isn’t going to do anything to enforce the laws requiring adequate staffing?

Seriously?

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. 

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Featured

Come with me, lesbian seagull

'Love Birds' doc dives into real-life scientific discovery that inspired a famous song—and dovetailed with gay rights movement.

Good Taste: Nibble at Nobu for a not-bad price

The Palo Alto hotel’s new Tanoshi Hour offers a kiss of opulence—and an entry point into the Chef Nobu Matsuhisa's world.

‘Club Kid’ tracks a partier’s transformation—but there’s an actual kid in an actual club, too

Director-star Jordan Firstman on his lauded debut's influences, the exhaustion of self-centeredness, and his surprise child's mad DJ skills

More by this author

Marina Safeway lawsuit will be a key test of the Wiener-Yimby agenda

Can a project with serious toxics issues get fast-track approval with no environmental review? The City Planning Dept. thinks so.

Homelessness? Evictions? Not the mayor’s priority

But thanking a billionaire who got rich from illegal conversion of apartments to hotel rooms? Sure.

The legacy of the late, great Harry Britt, who would not have backed Scott Wiener …

Plus: Homeless count soars, protecting hotel workers, and what will the mayor do about Crocker Amazon Park? That's The Agenda for Nov. 8-15
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED