Sponsored link
Monday, October 14, 2024

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsMichael Shellenberger, who says progressives ruin cities, has alarming transphobic tweets

Michael Shellenberger, who says progressives ruin cities, has alarming transphobic tweets

Why would anyone take this person's political opinions seriously any more?

-

When Rupert Murdoch’s company published Michael Shellenberger’s book, San Fransicko, in 2021, it got a fair amount of mainstream media attention. The New York Times reviewed it. The SF Standard did a point-counterpoint with me and Scott James.

Shellenberger ran for governor of California, and became a regular on cable news, attacking former DA Chesa Boudin.

Michael Shellenberger, Wikimedia Commons image.

But very little news media attention has focused on Shellenberger’s increasingly transphobic comments on Twitter.

Some of his social media likes ought to be shocking to anyone who cares about LGBTQ rights. And the more I read his Twitter feed, the more disturbing it gets.

At one point, he compares gender-affirming care for young people to the needless amputation of limbs.

He attacks “wokeness.”

He attacks the ACLU and GLAAD for “censorship.”

This is all happening at what trans activist Gabriel Haaland calls “the worst year in history for anti-trans and anti-drag legislation. It’s scary. And the likes of Michael Shellenberger are making it worse.

The Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention argues that the right-wing movement seeks to eradicate trans people:

We urge every person around the world to think about the precedents that are being set with the level of stigma, organized hate, and legal control being advocated by voices within the gender critical movement. We ask people to choose to protect the human rights of human beings who do not fit easily into the simplistic gender binary. We ask people to question what agendas they are serving by supporting anti-trans hate speech and policy initiatives. We encourage everyone to support people in their efforts to live as the person they know that they are.

And if you want to understand how bad mainstream journalism has been of late, take a look at this:

Journalists are failing at more than just reporting on the science. Mainstream publications like the Times increasingly follow the lead of anti-trans agitators, treating what should be understood as a fundamental human rights battle more like a semantic “debate,” fixating on terminology and labels and medical minutiae, instead of humanizing trans and nonbinary people and their experiences.

I always found Shellenberger’s ideas about homelessness and housing and crime in San Francisco to be foolish and wrong. But now I don’t think anyone should take this person seriously on any issue anymore.

I emailed him for comment, and (no surprise) he never responded.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

Featured

A hearing on Mayor’s Office corruption…

... Plus the cost of structural racism at SFPD—and a strange tale of how expensive it is to resell affordable housing. That's The Agenda for Oct. 14-21

Some (perhaps too optimistic) October Surprises

Trump offers his office space to the unhoused; Harris offers jobs to asylum seekers. We can still dream ....

UC’s unfair pay scales undermine crucial mental health treatment

A two-tiered system for clinical social workers leads to overwork, burnout, and worse outcomes for patients.

More by this author

A hearing on Mayor’s Office corruption…

... Plus the cost of structural racism at SFPD—and a strange tale of how expensive it is to resell affordable housing. That's The Agenda for Oct. 14-21

The school closure process is a disaster that never needed to happen

Close Harvey Milk and Yick Wo? After a bungled secretive process that has no credibility? Where are the School Board candidates?

Supes pass resolution seeking to avoid a sweeping attack on the Clean Water Act

Dorsey tries to say move is an attack on the City Attorney's Office, but that's not the issue—and by 8-2, members agree that the city should settle with the EPA over sewage
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED