Sponsored link
Sunday, September 14, 2025

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsDistrict 4 contender won't call for candidate with anti-Semitic comments to drop...

District 4 contender won’t call for candidate with anti-Semitic comments to drop out

Joel Engardio shows no indication that he wants Leanna Louie out of the race.

-

Most of political San Francisco is outraged at the shockingly anti-Semitic comments of District Four supe candidate Leanna Louie. She attacked MissionLocal columnist Joe Eskenazi, who has done a great job reporting on the fact that she might not have lived in the district long enough to run for supe—or might have voted illegally in another district.

Joel Engardio has stopped far short of calling for Leanna Louie to withdraw. Photo from his website.

Numerous local political leaders and news media outlets have called on her to drop out of the race.

But Joel Engardio, who is the candidate most likely to benefit from Louie taking Chinese votes away from incumbent Gordon Mar, has stopped a long way short of that.

Engardio denounced her comments in a message on Twitter:

When I contacted him, he said he is running “his own campaign.”

But even when I pressed him, he refused to call on Louie to withdraw from the race, and he refused to say that he would encourage his supporters not to vote for her.

Mayor London Breed has also failed to call on Louie to withdraw.

Here’s the cold political calculus:

Sponsored link

Help us save local journalism!

Every tax-deductible donation helps us grow to cover the issues that mean the most to our community. Become a 48 Hills Hero and support the only daily progressive news source in the Bay Area.

Engardio, a Breed ally, would have a very hard time beating Gordon Mar in a one-on-one race in a district with a large Chinese population. As long as Louie is in the race, and takes votes away from Mar, Engardio has a chance.

As a pure political decision, running a (subtle, unannounced) ranked-choice campaign with Louie helps Engardio. Both challengers can attack the incumbent, even from different political perspectives. Both can share second-place votes.

And while Louie is unlikely to win, if she stays in the race her second-place votes could elect Engardio.

If she is forced out by the City Attorney’s Office, or drops out because of her anti-Semitic rantings, Mar is the main beneficiary.

I ought to be a bit stunned that Engardio is unwilling to call on Louie to drop out, or to tell his supporters that they should never vote for someone with her record.

But this is San Francisco politics, and while Engardio talks about how awful and toxic and divisive it is, he’s not risking his own future to take a principled stand.

“In San Francisco, I always thought that we don’t give an inch to this kind of intolerance and sever ties whenever we see it,” Sup. Aaron Peskin told me. “The fact that somebody so badly wants to be a member of the Board of Supervisors that he can’t be a leader is very disturbing.”

The mayor is out of town. Presumably she has email. She could also make a statement. Or not.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Featured

Planning Commission passes Lurie plan over strong community opposition

Key measure advances to Board of Supes, where neighbors from the swing vote districts will be pitted against the mayor and the big developers

Best of the Bay 2025 Editors’ Pick: San Francisco Bay Area Bench Collective

Group's guerrilla seating makes solid statement about accessibility and humane public infrastructure.

Under the Stars: Superlative locals Umbrellas, Fake Fruit, Now take the SFMOMA roof

Plus: Upcoming gigs from Nirvana's favorite Shonen Knife, Devo and the B-52s, and The Saxophones' blue-lit beats.

More by this author

Mayor will face opponents to zoning plan at rallies outside of City Hall

Press conference, silent protest marks first official meeting on upzoning proposal. Here's what to look for

Opposition grows to Lurie’s zoning plan that would transform San Francisco

Tenants, neighborhood groups, and some supes are saying the plan will hurt renters and small businesses—and needs more environmental review

Defining land-use battle heads to supes, Planning Commission

Plus: Who wins when transit loses—and another giveaway to market-rate housing developers. That's The Agenda for Sept. 8-15
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED