Sponsored link
Thursday, September 18, 2025

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsElectionsBreed School Board appointee is now losing to progressive challenger

Breed School Board appointee is now losing to progressive challenger

Alida Fisher will likely replace Ann Hsu; Mar's hopes are dimming in D4.

-

(UPDATED with a correction)

Another one of Mayor Breed’s candidates in the November election just took a tumble, and now appears out of contention.

Ann Hsu, a leader in the School Board recall who was admonished by her own colleagues for a racist statement, has dropped out of the top three vote-getters and her numbers are falling as more votes come in, which means it’s likely progressive challenger Alida Fisher will take that seat.

A broad base of support: Former Sup. Sandra Lee Fewer, DCCC Member Peter Gallotta, Sup. Connie Chan, and former Sup. Bevan Dufty all backed Fisher.

Fisher, a special education advocate who had wide support across the city, pulled ahead over the weekend, is now up by 1,700 votes, and her lead is growing.

That means two of the three candidates endorsed by the Teacher’s Union will likely hold seats (Lisa Weissman-Ward is in first place).

It adds to a long list of flawed candidates Breed has appointed to public office who were rejected by the voters in the next election. Her candidate for District 5 supervisor, Vallie Brown, lost to Sup. Dean Preston. Her appointee to the Community College Board, Rodrigo Santos, not only lost re-election but was indicted in a corruption scandal.

She appears to have done better with Sup. Matt Dorsey, who has been re-elected in a gerrymandered District 6, and DA Brooke Jenkins, who won despite some serious ethics charges.

Jenkins will have to run again in two years, and I suspect there will be a serious campaign against her.

The District 4 race has been so close that I was unwilling to call it, but at this point it doesn’t look good for Sup. Gordan Mar. As votes come in, the margin of victory for Joel Engardio isn’t changing; every new count, he’s up by between 450 and 500 votes. Each day, the percentage of the remaining votes he will have to win increases, and at this point it’s more than 55 percent, which seems unlikely.

So Breed will have more allies on the Board of Supes, for two main reasons: Matt Haney decided his political ambition mattered more than the progressive community and agenda, and departed for Sacramento, giving Breed a D6 appointment. And Breed’s team successfully gerrymandered Districts 4 and 6 to make them more conservative.

The position of the Yimby ballot measure continues to deteriorate, and it will go down.

An earlier version of this story mis-identified the mayor who appointed Julie Christensen to a D3 seat, which she lost to Sup. Aaron Peskin. The late Mayor Ed Lee appointed Christensen, not Breed.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Featured

The Engardio recall, Yimby urbanist elitism, and the next step in SF politics

Is there a potential alliance around growth and development that brings together a broad range of voters?

Writer Michael Luo is ready for the happy ending

'Strangers in the Land' author shares what his deeply researched book on Chinese immigration history has in common with 'KPop Demon Hunters.'

Folsom 2025 brings Twisted Windows, joyful gates, a continually expanding Playground

Four of the kinky fair's players take us behind the juicy scenes (and history) of this year's fetish fest.

More by this author

The Engardio recall, Yimby urbanist elitism, and the next step in SF politics

Is there a potential alliance around growth and development that brings together a broad range of voters?

Voters recall Engardio, by huge margin

Now it's up to Lurie to appoint a D4 supe—and it won't be an easy choice

We will probably know Tuesday evening if Sup. Joel Engardio keeps his seat

Early results could tell the tale—and if the D4 supe is out, what will Lurie do?
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED