Sponsored link
Wednesday, April 17, 2024

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsCity HallSF building inspectors have no clue about gas pipes that could explode

SF building inspectors have no clue about gas pipes that could explode

Stunning revelations about a lack of enforcement of safety standards emerge from supes hearing.


There may be more than 1,000 residential properties in San Francisco that have unsafe gas lines that could lead to devastating fires – and the Department of Building Inspection doesn’t even know where they are and has no plans to find out.

That’s what came out of an extraordinary hearing at the Land Use and Transportation Committee today.

Sup. Hillary Ronen was stunned at how little the city knows about potential gas-line dangers

The hearing focused on information exposed by Joe Eskenazi at MissionLocal indicating that the city and builders, in their push to upgrade “soft-story” building to higher seismic safety standards, may have buried a bunch of gas lines inside concrete slabs.

That, the story notes, could be a serious problem: In an earthquake, the concrete could shake and possibly crack – and tear the gas line at the same time.

From Eskenazi’s story:

The ramifications here are chilling. Or, more correctly, burning: Steve Panelli, the Department of Building Inspection’s chief plumbing inspector, told the structural subcommittee [in 2017] that this situation was “unsafe” and a “life-safety issue.” 

“These are high-pressure lines,” he continued. “It could become, it could become … ” 

Panelli’s Building Department colleague David Leung finished the thought for him. 

“It could become a San Bruno.”  

Panelli concurred. “If one little leak happened and something happened here — it becomes catastrophic now. … It snowballs.”

The soft-story program mandates that buildings with several floors above, say, a garage, be upgraded; during the Loma Prieta quake, dozens of buildings that had unreinforced first floors collapsed.

Everyone agrees that it’s been a great success on one level – more than 5,000 property owners have done the upgrades.

But according to DBI officials who testified today, in at least a third of those cases (we’re talking maybe 1,500 buildings) the upgrades involved pouring a horizontal concrete beam at the ground level – and sometimes that meant moving a gas line through the concrete.

At this point, the story gets a little technical – and weird.

Under questioning from Sup. Hillary Ronen, DBI officials said that the Building Code requires those pipes to be in a “sleeve” – typically a PVC pipe that gives the pipe an inch or so clearance on either side to move around in a quake.

But the code also allows “other authorized” protections, which might be a “wrap,” which might be made out of material that would prevent cracking, but might not be – and nobody really knows which systems are where.

And since DBI decides what is “authorized,” and the code is totally vague, then inspectors don’t enforce rules on what some experts say are critical safety measures.

PG&E officials say the sleeve is the only safe system. An expert from Santa Clara, Douglas Hansen, said that “wrapping” a pipe in some sort of protective material – and there are no rules on what it should be — often doesn’t protect it from the problems you get when you bury it in concrete.

But it turns out that in San Francisco, the contractor and the structural engineer doing the work decided what system to use, and there’s no rule that the engineer even visit the site, and – this left Ronen stunned – there is nothing in any report, anywhere, that tracks whether the proper system was used.

“How do we know if the pipeline was sleeved or wrapped?” she asked.

The answer: We don’t.

What is DBI going to do now to go back and see if there are serious safety issues?


Part of the issue here is the weird jurisdiction issues between the city and PG&E.

The private company owns, operates, and is responsible for the gas mains, and the lines that connect them to the meters in houses. After the meter, all gas lines are under the jurisdiction of DBI.

But the infrastructure in this city is pretty old, so in some houses, the meter in inside, say, a garage – so after a seismic upgrade, the gas line that passes through the concrete beam would be pre-meter, and thus – DBI says – out of their jurisdiction.

 That means the only “building inspection” for those sleeves, or wraps, or maybe nothing, comes from PG&E. Builders, Eskenazi notes, often avoid PG&E because the company takes so long to get to a site.

So they just pour concrete, and maybe it’s safe and maybe it isn’t. And the city doesn’t even know.

PG&E, at least, seems interested in going back to check on the lines in its jurisdiction – maybe, if it was notified in the first place that construction was happening.

DBI, Ronen confirmed, has no such plans at all.

This, I think any reasonable person would acknowledge, is a serious problem.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.


Good Taste: Local chefs serve kitchen game on social media

Victoriano Lopez and Kathy Fang share go-to cooking techniques when they’re off the clock. Watch and learn!

Gaza protesters on Golden Gate Bridge jailed on felony charges

Unusual CHP tactic guaranteed that 26 people spend at least one night behind bars.

Screen Grabs: Berlin & Beyond &… Milli Vanilli?

The German-language film fest keeps broadening its borders. Plus: Ken Loach's finale 'Old Oak' and 'Dig! XX'

More by this author

Gaza protesters on Golden Gate Bridge jailed on felony charges

Unusual CHP tactic guaranteed that 26 people spend at least one night behind bars.

The city’s budget battle comes into clear view ….

.... Plus broken elevators in SROs, a mess in the city's housing voucher program—and where did Breed's 'Dreamkeeper' money go? That's The Agenda for April 14-21

Wildly inaccurate story leads to death threats for activist, 48hills writer

Lisa Gray Garcia, who writes as Tiny, gets attacked after New York Post does a sensational story about her work with UCLA medical students.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED