Sponsored link
Monday, March 17, 2025

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsNo, she's not the Mom of the Year

No, she’s not the Mom of the Year

If this country must praise a slap heard around the world, I mourn for its rock-bottom expectations with regard to black motherhood and parenthood in general

Photo from http://freakoutnation.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Mom.jpg
Photo from http://freakoutnation.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Mom.jpg

By Kevin Bard

APRIL 29, 2015 — I had a feeling this would go viral. Why shouldn’t it? A black woman in Baltimore slapping her “thug” son for not obeying the rules in the middle of yet another anti-violence protest against the police.

For some, this public shaming is vigilantism done right. Besides, isn’t the idea of seeing a nigga-ish black man get beaten too irresistible to question, no matter who delivers the blows?

Black resistance to police brutality has always been tempered by concerns for property damage. As Freak Out Nation puts it, “In a city devastated by violence that has left 15 officers injured — six seriously — from thrown bottles, rocks and bricks, as well as dozens of businesses, homes and cars damaged or destroyed by looting or arson, this Mom has had it.”

Hence, Toya Graham’s apparent Mother of the Year award/hashtag.

If this country must praise a slap heard around the world, I mourn for its rock-bottom expectations with regard to black motherhood and parenthood in general. A racist system doesn’t really care if you are violent or not. A racist system also doesn’t really care if you are violent to your children or not.

In Ms. Graham’s interview with CBS News, as reported in The Hill, she says, “That’s my only son, and at the end of the day I don’t want him to be a Freddie Gray,” earning obvious praise from the Baltimore Police Commissioner Anthony Batts. But if her son’s spine were to be broken someday in the future while under arrest, whose fault would that actually be?

Sponsored link

Help us save local journalism!

Every tax-deductible donation helps us grow to cover the issues that mean the most to our community. Become a 48 Hills Hero and support the only daily progressive news source in the Bay Area.

This correct-the-thug argument has a three-fold utility: it justifies beating children, police brutality, and the prison-industrial-complex – all in one swoop. It perpetuates the unwritten idea that black men who use nigga are incapable of understanding anything other than the violence that that word often entails. This narrative also suggests that certain black men must be constantly restricted. As Commissioner Batts puts it, “Take control of your kids.” Or the Baltimore police will do it for you.

I am no sociologist, but I will nevertheless venture that African American child abuse is often correlated to the anti-social behavior that the police often target – with violent consequences.

Perhaps it is easier (and more profitable) to police structural racism and multi-generational poverty than it is to actually solve them. Is this a standing American recommendation?

You teach with words and behavior, not fists or batons. Violence is actually the absence of a communal language, and what is happening right now in Baltimore (as a result of the horrific killing of Freddie Gray) proves that point. Who cares if Gray was running away? Thugs runaway from the rule-makers all the time. He was playing the role of a black man on the way to receiving corrective violence. As was Toya Graham’s son. Two peas in a pod, for some.

But what if moral lessons are somehow generated by a mother’s slap, or a father’s fist, or a cracked back, or a cop’s lethal chokehold? Then I can say, will all certitude, I want nothing to do with morality.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

Sponsored link

Sponsored link

Featured

This is one disease I thought I wouldn’t have to worry about. Wrong.

Plus: Is SF moving away from harm reduction and Housing First? That's The Agenda for March 17-24

The magical little Grotto where writers boost up

Storied scribe support center The Writers Grotto in the Mission celebrates 30 years of collaborative wordsmithery.

A tsunami of chaos and destruction, but there may be hope

There's a car salesman in the White House and an evil billionaire in your Social Security file, yet cracks are starting to show.

More by this author

Letters we answer: Pelosi, Newsom, trans athletes …

... and are taxes really too high in San Francisco?

Lurie won’t commit to an alternative approach to the opioid crisis

Mayor doubles down on law enforcement, rejects Fielder's call for a 'Four Pillars' approach that has worked in other cities

How is SF going to approach drug dealing? There are very different proposals

Plus: A report on police misconduct, and a documentary on the vulture capital firm that is destroying local news. That's The Agenda for March 9-16

You might also likeRELATED