Wednesday, April 14, 2021
News + Politics COVID Give prisoners the vaccine

Give prisoners the vaccine

Prisons and jails are COVID super-spreaders -- and that makes all of us less safe.


Inmates in federal prisons, state prisons and local jails should be in the first cohort of people to be offered COVID-19 vaccinations.

One in five prisoners in the US has been reported to have been infected with COVID-19. That’s 20 percent of people behind bars. And that is likely a “vast undercount,” according to Homer Venters, the former chief medical officer at New York’s Rikers Island jail complex.

A huge outbreak in San Quentin spread to the outside community.

If compassion for prisoners does not move policy makers or the general public, then eyes should turn to a pair of recent studies, one by the Prison Policy Initiative and the other by the Marshall Project, focused on prisons and jails in the U.S. According to data in these two reports:

  • Prisons and jails are “super-spreaders” of the virus, not only among prisoners, but also among people in the communities where prisons and jails are located. It may be hard for a prisoner to break out of jail, but the virus gets out easily, hosted by guards, maintenance staff, and visitors.

  • Prisons and jails were responsible for more than half a million reported COVID-19 infections, 566,804 to be exact – in May, June and July alone.
  • A big majority of those half-a-million-plus infections were among people who are not incarcerated, rather in the communities in which our prisons and jails are located.
  • If those 566,804 people were a country, that country would rank fifth in the world for reported COVID-19 infections for this period – right after the US, Brazil, India, and Russia.
  • The state with the largest number of prison and jail related infections is California, with 113,969 cases – again, in May, June and July alone. The infection rate among prisoners in California is even higher than in the country as a whole – one in four, or 25 percent.

  • The community with the largest number of prison and jail related infections in the country is the Los Angeles-Long Beach-Riverside area, as defined by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA), with 94,221 casesduring those three months.
  • The San Francisco-Oakland-San Jose area, as defined by the BEA, ranked 17th in the nation with 5,298 prison and jail related infections.

Are all you “free” men and women feeling safe right now?

In August, California Governor Gavin Newsom announced that Ralph Diaz, the former head of the California state prison system, would retire in October. Diaz had been the target of sharp criticisms for his approval of a transfer of 121 prisoners from the prison in Chino to San Quentin. This transfer, by all accounts, resulted in a massive COVID-19 outbreak in San Quentin, including 28 reported deaths, so far.

Assemblymember Marc Levine, a Democrat whose district includes San Quentin, has been quoted saying that “The spread of COVID-19 at state prisons was a preventable public health disaster and a failure of CDCR [California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation] leadership at the highest level.”

That “highest level” should include Newsom. It is hard to believe that Newsom was unaware of Diaz’ approval of the Chino transfer. Newsom has also done little in response to demands that the prison population be spread out and thinned out in order to prevent the “public health disaster” that our system of mass incarceration has spawned.

Infections among prisoners show no sign of slowing down. In fact, last week the surge of new COVID-19 cases in US prisons reached the highest level to date. We are all, prisoners and non-prisoners alike, suffering the consequences.

The least Newsom could do is to arrange to offer the vaccine to state prisoners, for the safety of all Californians.



    “As the coronavirus sweeps through prisons, killing the incarcerated, their friends and family members on the outside often suffer without a final goodbye or even basic information about how their loved one got sick or was treated.

    “There’s now an online memorial – – which helps gather information about those prisoners who have died of COVID-19.”

  2. The vaccine is not going to be distributed to the population until Biden gets in office and has a plan. A major logistical problem like this can not be solved with out comprehensive extensive planning and implementation between federal, state and local authorities. Expecting the pharmacists at Walgreens to vaccinate the population isn’t going to happen.

  3. This is why the left fails to gain traction, because the messaging reduces to: no matter how bad your life is, there are people who are worse off than you, so we’re going to deny your trauma and maybe get to it after everyone else has been attended to, which, at the rate we’re going, will not be in your lifetime.

  4. You need to consider 1. Who is most likely to die without the vaccine? 2. Who is most likely to spread to others?
    Realistically, the next month is not going to have proper distribution, until Biden takes office because there is no central planning of distribution. This really needs to be done by the federal government.

  5. My dear 70 year old friend is way over his mandatory sentence and has a clean record for over 30 years, but remains at Lancaster vulnerable and packed in that overcrowded CA State prison. When 20% of the prison population has been infected, prison staff, especially correctional officers ARE front line workers.

  6. So – who should prisoners be in front of to get the vaccine, Marc? Seniors, Front line workers, teachers?

Comments are closed.

More by this author

State data shows COVID spread alarmingly at workplaces

The virus appears to have been infecting people at their jobs, not just at family parties and social events.

No cell phone? No vaccine.

Seniors who aren't tech-savvy and don't have cell phones are completely left out of the vaccination process in SF.

The Super Bowl billionaires

Sports team owners, including Charles Johnson of the Giants, made $98.5 billion during the pandemic. Their stadium workers are suffering.

Covering up workplace COVID

The law says employers have to report virus outbreaks and health departments have to make that public. It hasn't happened.

Give prisoners the vaccine

Prisons and jails are COVID super-spreaders -- and that makes all of us less safe.

Most read

City College students fight back against brutal faculty cuts

Firing teachers could also mean the end of a lot of treasured programs.

There’s a lot more to the GG Park debate than cars v. bikes

This is part of a huge discussion the city needs to have about transportation -- and equity -- in a post-COVID world.

Reese Erlich, foreign correspondent and radical reporter, is dead at 73

After a life of progressive politics, ground-breaking journalism, and social activism, a legendary writer loses battle with cancer.

With live shows poised to return, musicians open up about opening up

An indie star, a label owner, a DJ, and an electronic musician share their candid responses to this moment

Breed won’t promise to spend real-estate tax money on rent relief

The voters approved Prop. I last fall to support tenants and affordable housing, but the mayor says she will use the money for her own priorities.

You might also likeRELATED