Sponsored link
Saturday, January 11, 2025

Sponsored link

UncategorizedPolitics on Tuesday: Private phones, public business

Politics on Tuesday: Private phones, public business

What if the mayor is communicating with his aides, his allies, local businesses, whatever, with his personal email and cell phone, doing public business in a way that avoids the intent of the open-records laws?

This came up early in the Obama administration, when the president was allowed to keep his BlackBerry, but only with additional security features. His emails will be part of the public record forever, under the Presidential Records Act.

But that doesn’t trickle down to the local level, where I’ve many times sought email records from city officials only to be told that they “don’t exist.” That’s probably because they exist on private phones and email accounts.

As far as I know, this question has never been tested in court. But if everyone’s doing what Christie’s aides are doing, it makes a mockery of any public records law.

Let’s suppose that, as with Chris Christie’s staff, the mayor (or a senior aide) has been using his private cell phone to text with Ron Conway about another tech-industry tax break. And along the way, he mentions that there’s a city contract coming up that one of Conway’s companies ought to bid on. That’s city business, and it absolutely ought to be public; if he’d used a city email account, it would be.

But his personal cell phone? Or his personal email? Maybe not.

There is massive potential for mischief here.

Could the city decide that, while it’s fine to use personal electronic devices for official business, those texts have to be made public and can’t be deleted (as per city Sunshine law?) Or could the city decide that it’s against the rules to use private devices to engage in official city business? How do we deal with this? Because this is how public business is done now. In secret.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Marke B.
Marke B.
Marke Bieschke is the publisher and arts and culture editor of 48 Hills. He co-owns the Stud bar in SoMa. Reach him at marke (at) 48hills.org, follow @supermarke on Twitter.

Sponsored link

Sponsored link

Featured

A great LGBTQ ally dies… and so does a great villain

'70s boycotts were their battlefields, but Allan Baird and Anita Bryant were as different as beer and orange juice.

Ficks’ Picks: Best flicks of 2024, part two

The big buff blaze of 'Love Lies Bleeding,' a shout-out to Sade, 'Megalopolis,' and more superlative reels.

‘Nickel Boys’ has a horrific backstory, but ‘love is at the core of it’

Director RaMell Ross on adapting Colson Whitehead's novel of systematic racism and abuse into a highly subjective film.

More by this author

Adorable free ‘Muni Routle’ game tests your SF transit knowledge

Hop aboard the city's latest obsession: an online daily quiz for transportation geeks—and folks just waiting for the bus.

Beloved Lower Haight artist Pete Doolittle has died

His brightly-colored iconography, painted mostly on discarded windows, came to represent the rapidly changing neighborhood.

Party Radar: 11 last-minute NYE (+ NYD) picks for your cork-popping delectation

Our 'pick of the litter' for a sweet, sweet eve—plus our infamous Comedowns Are For Losers New Year's Day list.
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED