Sponsored link
Friday, July 11, 2025

Sponsored link

Will Mel Murphy force a trial? So far, he’s defiant

Commissioner’s lawyer says he’s not ready to step down. Will the mayor suspend him?

Port Commission Member Mel Murphy isn't ready to step down
Port Commission Member Mel Murphy isn’t ready to step down

By Tim Redmond

APRIL 6, 2014 — Eighty percent of San Francisco voters agree that a commission member who violates the laws he or she oversees should be fired, a new poll by Friends of Ethics shows. That’s hardly a surprise, but it highlights the embarrassment that Port Commission member (and former Building Inspection Commission member) Mel Murphy has caused for Mayor Ed Lee.

The poll, just released today, was based on the responses of 569 voters reached by Pubic Policy Polling.

The mayor gets the message: As of today, Matier and Ross report, he has called on Murphy to resign. There’s only one problem:

Nobody seems to be able to reach the guy.

“We’d been trying to call him, but he wasn’t calling back,” said one source close to the mayor. “We still haven’t heard from him.”

But I contacted Murphy’s attorney, Andrew Zachs, who gave me the following statement:

Mr. Murphy is reviewing the allegations made by the City Attorney against him and will respond to the Mayor’s request in due course.  A lawsuit involves unproven allegations.  As our sitting Sheriff can attest, removal from office (including the Port Commission) requires actual proof of official misconduct.  Commissioner Murphy is entitled to due process and all presumptions in his favor.  The Mayor’s Office has not responded to my phone calls regarding the basis for his demand for resignation and appears to seek a rush to judgment against Commissioner Murphy based on unproven allegations.

So Murphy knows he’s been asked to resign by the mayor, and isn’t ready to do it. He may force the mayor to suspend him, at which point we could have a trial before both the Ethics Commission and the Board of Supervisors – at which all sorts of interesting stuff could come out about the Department of Building Inspection.

I also like this from the Mayor Office: Gee, they didn’t realize how bad things were until they read the city attorney’s lawsuit:

“There were things in there that we didn’t know about,” the mayoral source said.

Really? They didn’t know about things like this?

Now, of course, the mayor can suspend Murphy at any time, the same way he suspended Sheriff Ross Mirkarimi. No word from the Mayor’s Office on whether that’s imminent.

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram

Sponsored link

Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Latest

Britney blackout: Author Jeff Weiss relives the ’00s pop culture cataclysm

Music journalist's gonzo new book 'Waiting for Britney Spears' dives into the tabloid-strewn wreck of the schlocky decade.

Under the Stars: Madlib’s sonic crystal ball spins again

Plus: Kendra Morris scores a reggae-tinged 'Flat Tire,' Jay Som rocks back with 'Float,' Directions in Stereo dips into the wax stacks

Good Taste: An obsessive early guide to the Outside Lands food multiverse

Fun bevs, free samples, fries as meals, super splurges, and more: It’s not too soon to plan your festival menu.

Unplugging with Yeah Yeah Yeahs

Adding stalwart guitarist Imaad Wasif, the indie heroes hit Symphony Hall to explore their acoustic side—and some new emotional textures.

You might also likeRELATED