Sponsored link
Sunday, October 1, 2023

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsPoliceFour takeaways from the historic Police Commission vote this week

Four takeaways from the historic Police Commission vote this week

A progressive commission is becoming the focus of broader criminal-justice reform issues.


The San Francisco Police Commission voted 4-2 Wednesday night to enact one one of the most sweeping restrictions on pretext traffic stops in the country, thrilling community advocates and establishing a pro-reform majority on a panel traditionally controlled by the mayor.

Commissioner Max Carter-Oberstone was the leader on the pretext-stop policy. Sfgovtv photo.

Mayor London Breed opposed some of the policy changes, and two of her appointees voted against them (Debra Walker, who also appeared to oppose the changes, had left the meeting by the time the vote took place).

Eleni Balakrishnan has a great moment-by-moment description of the meeting at MissionLocal.

The vote came after Harold Medlock, the retired police chief of Fayetteville North Carolina, gave a detailed presentation of his efforts to end racist policing by curtailing pretext stops and directing officers not to pull over motorists for minor traffic offenses.

It was pretty compelling, and you can watch it here.

The leader in this effort, Max Carter-Oberstone, is a Breed appointee who stood up to the mayor and set off a big debate about her efforts to make appointees sign undated letters of resignation.

Here are a four takeaways:

The battle between the criminal-justice reform movement and the mayor and district attorney is now happening at the Police Commission. With no election this year, everyone from the Public Defender’s Office to the ACLU is now looking to the commission as a place where the city can still make reforms—and not just on police accountability and discipline but on law-enforcement policy.

Breed specifically complained about that when she spoke to the Board of Supes, saying that an “unelected commission” (never mind that she appointed a majority of the members) shouldn’t be deciding what laws the cops should and shouldn’t follow. Expect more of this.

This Police Commission, unlike some other policy panels in the city, seems determined to work independently; Breed’s consistent attempts to get Carter-Oberstone to back down from his advocacy haven’t worked. That’s a good signal for future reform efforts.

The commission isn’t afraid of the Police Officers Association. In fact, little noticed in the coverage is a part of the resolution that calls on the city not to “meet and confer” with the POA on anything but very limited elements of the new policy. That’s a big step: The POA has used the tactic of demanding meet-and-confer sessions to delay a long list of reforms.

At some point, someone in the news media (I’m guessing Dion Lim at Channel 7) is going to find some instance, somewhere, at some point, where an officer failed to pull someone over for a broken tail light and the driver went on to rob a bank or run over a pedestrian or something else heinous, and the rest of the press will climb on, and we will hear that the policy is endangering public safety. Nobody will both to mention the thousands of Black and Brown people who avoided illegal searches, hassles, and in some cases injuries as a result of pretext stops, because, of course, in SF’s major media world, that isn’t news.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

Top reads

‘Jeopardy!’ champ Amy Schneider does not want to be your favorite trans person on TV

On the eve of her appearance at Porchlight Storytelling's Litquake edition, the beloved game show guru and memoir author isn't holding back.

Welcome to Best of the Bay 2023!

Thousands voted in our 49th annual Readers' Poll, celebrating the best place on Earth. Here are the results.

Live Shots: The agony and the ecstasy of Folsom Street Fair 2023

A more relaxed vibe this year, but freak flags still flew high. View our unbridled pics

More by this author

Breed looks for political points by finding more ways to punish poor people

The latest: Drug testing for welfare recipients, which will never work and probably never happen. Do we live in San Francisco or Texas?

A chron oped on the housing hearing is wrong, and signals a new attack on the supes

Board members asked for a modest delay to consider the mayor's amendments to a complex housing bill. The Chron talks of "Nimbys."

How will the city implement forced treatment for people with mental illness?

Plus: Does the Mayor's Office have a real homelessness plan—and what's going to happen new to Laguna Honda Hospital? That's The Agenda this week
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED