Monday, September 28, 2020
Arts + Culture Music In a time for Black voices, the terrific 'High...

In a time for Black voices, the terrific ‘High Fidelity’ gets canceled. Why?

Zoë Kravitz's show updated musty stereotypes about music and brought color back to Brooklyn streets. Now, it's gone.


Welp, I was wrong. HULU may actually be an acronym for stupid.

As we move with GREAT hesitation these days—government mishandled pandemics and all—the need for Black Voices reminds me of one of my fave De La Soul recs: Stakes Is High.

We mourned publicly over the murder of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, marched for justice, burned shit down in disgust, trying to be heard by a larger populace. We removed racist statues, bringing newfound sensibility about Black Lives to a section of America that finally could not look away.

From ESPN to CNN, Black trauma was on display, non-stop, on every breaking news segment. Colin Kaepernick, taking a knee protest against the deaths of African-Americans at the hands of police, even went from villain to hero in certain parts of America, overnight. (And now we see the leaders of the sports industrial complex rush to put athletes in harm’s way, fulfilling billion-dollar television contracts to distract—er, entertain—the growing amount of unemployed Americans.)

All of this took place after HULU’s High Fidelity series, starring Zoë Kravitz, premiered on Valentines’ Day this year. Feels like a decade ago huh? Last week the streaming platform canceled the show after one season. Kravitz starred as Rob, a pop culture-obsessed record store owner in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, who allows personal baggage over several relationships, to disintegrate her for one year.

This gender-switched, queer-friendly modern retelling of the Nick Hornby novel, formerly adapted into a 2000 film—starring John Cusack and Kravitz’s mother, Lisa Bonet—garnered an 86 percent positive rating on Rotten Tomatoes and received a warm reception from fans and critics alike. Finally, Zoe Kravitz, a Black actor, playing a bisexual lead, gets the vehicle to show us what we always suspected. She IS a star. “Big Little Lies” can go kick rocks. You root for this character and actor putting themselves out there in a raw, funny, and vulnerable way. Kravitz owns the “Fruity Pebbles monologue” space.

Robyn aka Rob owns a record store in Crown Heights that has a diverse staff who can pop off at any moment in any direction of music. You may disagree with the takes, but the acumen cannot be disputed.
Don’t date anybody who likes Phish. Just saying. Unlike HBO’s “Girls,” this Brooklyn has Black and brown folk visibly cruising down Franklin Ave with great ease. “High Fidelity” was Written by Sarah Kucserka and Veronica West, the award-winning writers of “Ugly Betty,” and executive produced by Kravitz, who was in that writer’s room a lot.

It’s a huge loss right now for representation in a subject area that still seems stuck in the 1980s. Growing up, the only Black cultural critic I knew of talking about rock was JJ Jackson, one of MTV’s five original VJs. With all the waxing poetic I’ve had to endure by skinny white dudes, with suspect mustaches, riding fixed gear bikes, telling me, about Wu-Tang and J Dilla? Please. As my closest folks know. I LOVE BLACK PEOPLE SPEAKING ON ROCK AND ROLL. We made that.

So kicking it with cool ass Zoë/Rob over the course five hours, cruising around BK in Hawaiian leisure shirts, long brown leather coat, and jeans? Watching the daughter of Lenny Kravitz—who had a hard time back in the day getting his rock-oriented music video’s played on BET—lighting fools up on how Fleetwood Macʻs Tusk is better than Rumours. “Tiger King” be damned, “High Fidelity” was streaming balm.

And it was a rare reboot that actually worked. Synthesizing cultural criticism from outliers—mostly a Black perspective—with action that we, being in quarantine, cannot take part in. Going to a dimly lit dive, sitting elbow to elbow, talking shit with your peoples about the impact Ariel Pink made on LA’s contemporary musical landscape or the genius-type Quincy Jones horn charts on Thriller, ESG bumping from over-worked speakers while sipping on cheap whiskey.

These things, we can’t have right now, combined with a disenfranchised brain trust of cultural identifiers, makes the loss of this High Fidelity worthy of all the upset comments on social media from fellow Black media stars Lena Waithe, Questlove, tessa Thompson, and of course Kravitz herself, who responded to cancellation, “It’s cool. At least Hulu has a ton of other shows starring women of color we can watch. Oh wait.”

John-Paul Shiver
John-Paul Shiver has been contributing to 48 Hills since 2019. His work as an experienced music journalist and pop culture commentator has appeared in the Wire, Resident Advisor, SF Weekly, Bandcamp Daily, PulpLab, AFROPUNK, and Drowned In Sound.

More by this author

Hardly Strictly Bluegrass announces full lineup—and $1 million artist relief

The beloved fest returns online with archived and new performances, and direct help for musicians

Local Listen: Sounds for your next Bay Area beat session

From party crew As You Like It's new label to Mix Master Mike and Steve Jordan's expansive 'Beat Odyssey 2020,' our new local music column turns on to the musical wealth in our midst.

From Herbie Hancock to Angela Davis: Monterey Jazz Fest comes to you

Moving online and back to its roots, the 63rd installment of the legendary fest focuses on history and support of Black community.

Naima Shalhoub wields strength of community on debut studio album ‘SIPHR’

The multi-faceted Oakland musician summons Lebanese heritage on follow-up to 'Live in San Francisco County Jail.'

Now Watch This: Ride away the summer on these 5 new music videos

It's all in the visuals for this second installation of our music video column—with new work from Fontaines D.C., Frank Ivy, Sylvan Esso, and more.

Most read

Finally, a state Senate debate

Plus: The municipal corruption scandal and the state of the city's economy. That's The Agenda for Sept. 28-Oct. 4

Hardly Strictly Bluegrass announces full lineup—and $1 million artist relief

The beloved fest returns online with archived and new performances, and direct help for musicians

Club mogul accused of vigilante homeless sweep says he did nothing wrong

Peter Glikshtern says he called private trash crew to encampment, insists he was justified by city inaction.

An epic, equitable ‘Power Shift’ for Hope Mohr Dance’s latest

Anti-racism training, Magic squares, 'Space Carcasses,' more refocus on BIPOC improvisation practitioners for company's Bridge Project.

New Music: Electronic tracks touch down, from Moor Mother to Mauritius

Avalon Emerson, Otik, Chiminyo, more bring sounds from around the dance floor world.

Foreign Correspondent: The turmoil in Belarus

Belarusian political activists face a difficult situation, caught between a ruthless dictator and a potential Western takeover of their country.

Banjos, bandanas, & a Monkee—the scene at Hardly Strictly Bluegrass

The weather was gorgeous and the crowd broke records at the 19th annual Hardly Strictly Bluegrass, which seemed to include a lot more roots...

The latest nasty — and inaccurate — attack on Chesa Boudin

No, the DA's Office did not release a burglary suspect who went on to attempt a rape.

A displacement housing bill barely dies — but it will come back

Measure to turn any single-family lot into four units -- with zero affordable housing -- is the top of the Scott Wiener/Yimby agenda.

Nancy Pelosi just announced her retirement

Rep. Nancy Pelosi cut a deal that will put her in the position of House speaker for four more years (assuming the Democrats retain...

You might also likeRELATED