Sunday, April 18, 2021
News + Politics Labor A union at Google? Here's why

A union at Google? Here’s why

Organizers explain why tech workers need representation too.


A lot of people think that tech workers have it made—high salary, great benefits, fancy catered lunches eaten while sitting on bean bags, and now pretty much unlimited working from home. Google’s original motto was even “Don’t be evil,” exuding optimism and confidence in a brighter tomorrow.

In recent years, however, that reputation has begun to falter. More than half of the people who work Google now are temporary workers, vendors, or contractors, who often earn less, get worse, if any, benefits, lack robust protections against discrimination, and are disproportionately people of color compared to employees at Google.

And this week, about 220 workers at Alphabet and its sister companies, including Google, formally announced that they are unionizing; membership has already almost doubled to more than 400. The Alphabet Workers Union is focused on ensuring that workers have the right to refuse to work on projects they deem unethical, holding perpetrators of harassment and discrimination accountable, and to improving worker conditions, particularly for TVCs. Union dues are set at one percent of total compensation.

“There’s no one kind of tech worker,” Dylan Baker, software engineer on Google’s ethical AI team, who has been active in the union since it was started roughly a year ago. I’m a queer, trans person, wasn’t a computer science major, didn’t come from techie parents … Google’s trying to enforce this tiered structure, where half of the employees get all these perks and benefits and the things Google is famous for, the massages and free lunches, and then the other half of the workforce has a lot more precarity, they earn a lot less, and is in need of a lot more of the union protections—better pay, paid vacation,” said Baker.

“We weren’t interested in forming a union that was solely for high-paid tech workers,” said Parul Koul, executive chair of the AWU. “This is the first wall-to-wall union that includes everybody that works at [Alphabet], regardless of classification.”

The importance of unionizing, also comes after recent issues with sexual harassment as well as ethically dubious projects by Google, such as Project Maven, where Google created drone technology for the Pentagon, sparking outrage among thousands of Google workers. The power to opt-out of projects and conflict with workers’ values is particularly important to workers who are likely to be employees, such as software engineers. For Baker, one moment that was disturbing for them was the recent ousting of their manager, Timnit Gebru, a computer scientist who led Google’s Ethical AI research team.

“She was fired really suddenly…It really got to me. Working in ethical AI feels sort of like how ExxonMobil had all this cutting-edge climate change research in the sixties and seventies, and then they started defunding it, and by the nineties they were pouring millions [of dollars] into actively refuting their own research…it feels like we’re in a similar place with AI. AI is dramatically shaping the world we live in and people are working really, really hard at finding out what’s going on, how can we stop it, and they’re getting fired and they’re getting pushed out. I’ve watched my own projects and team’s projects get sidelined, stopped, ignored, not invited to meetings. It’s ludicrous,” said Baker.

In the short term, organizing is likely to be limited to supporting employee activism that we have seen so far, with future hopes of getting collective bargaining powers down the line. The AWU has formed without federal ratification by the NLRB, which means it cannot collectively bargain with Alphabet, but Parul Koul, the union’s executive chair, said that the union is currently focused on growing its numbers and training members to organize and run campaigns successfully, which will in turn recruit union members.

Koul said the first step is outreach. “We’re going to bring people in, and get them have to get people trained to organize, and then actually run campaigns and win the demands that we talk about,” said Koul. “I think through that process, we are going to be able to show people that we can actually get together and use our collective strength to win real change in the workplace. I think that’s what’s ultimately going to convince thousands and thousands of people over time that this is a worthwhile effort.”

The training comes from the Communications Workers of America Local 1400, who the Alphabet Workers Union is affiliated with. Part of the reason that training is needed, according to Baker, was because workers in tech are not familiar with organizing—unions are rare in tech, unlike other trades. The CWA has helped other fledgling unions with organizing and training before a majority of staff had signed union cards upon going public, such as United Campus Workers of Georgia.

While the union is still in its infancy, going public has already helped some union members morale, in spite of the now-present threat of retaliation.

“It’s better to be organizing now, even though this thing feels so huge and so involved,” Koul said. “If we were to experience retaliation, we have the CWA on our side, union dues that we can use for supporting people who may lose their jobs, access to labor lawyers. I actually feel safer than I have in the past, with hundreds of people behind my back.”


  1. I’m a queer, trans person, wasn’t a computer science major, didn’t come from techie parents … Google’s trying to enforce this tiered structure, where half of the employees get all these perks and benefits and the things Google is famous for, the massages and free lunches, and then the other half of the workforce has a lot more precarity, they earn a lot less, and is in need of a lot more of the union protections—better pay, paid vacation,” said Baker.

    Why Mr. Baker is surprised that programmers and developers with computer science degrees make more money and have better benefits than a queer studies major, I haven’t a clue. But having a union won’t equalize the two.

    I’m not throwing shade on the union or google but 200 workers are about .1% of google’s workforce. The article I read didn’t distinguish between full time and contractors. It’s very common for technology companies and IT departments to have a large number of contractors; 30% isn’t uncommon. And they’re not necessarily paid less either; indeed, sometimes they can make quite a bit more money if they have a skill that’s in high demand.

    There was a post about this on LinkedIn with a lot of comments. Basically I don’t think google is such a great company anymore and Amazon is much worse, as far as working conditions.

  2. organized labor has been failing for at least half a century. maybe the whole idea needs a radical reworking or even throwing out out entirely. it’s just way to easy to subvert union leadership by offering them more money than they can say no to. I see labor unions making incredibly poor decisions with awful political outcomes and the only explanation that makes sense to me is their leadership is compromised and they’re being sabotaged from within. remember the hotel workers strike that lasted for months? and then one day people started showing up protesting the New Green Deal saying it was bad for workers? maybe it is, but they were picking a fight with the public whose support they had been propping them up. whose idea was that? find out. that’s your inside enemy.

Comments are closed.

More by this author

A ‘double celebration:’ Unionization moves forward at two local companies

Dandelion Chocolate workers hope to join Tartine Bakery workers, who just won a contested election for union representation.

Thousands rally against hate crimes

Large turnout for event focused on anti-Asian violent incidents.

Dandelion Chocolate workers move to form union

Another local business could be represented by ILWU Local 6.

Homeless people lack access to water

People on SF's streets can't even access the UN's minimum requirements for potable water, new report shows.

Lawsuit says San Jose police violence caused serious injuries

Cops injured people (including a state Assembly member) with needless weapons, says complaint demanding reforms.

Most read

How To Reopen Nightlife: Enough with the boys’ club, make room for women

DJ femmelectric and promoter Alex McGeagh speak about equity, access, and safety for women and nonbinary folks.

Family child care: A real business that makes a big impact on a community

Teaching Behind the Mask: Why FCCs need more resources -- and respect.

Radical right group is trying to attack public-sector labor in SF

Anti-union mailers are going to workers home addresses -- but really, this group is looking pretty desperate.

Breed won’t promise to spend real-estate tax money on rent relief

The voters approved Prop. I last fall to support tenants and affordable housing, but the mayor says she will use the money for her own priorities.

New COVID-conscious Kapwa Gardens celebrates Filipino culture

Outdoor activity site in SOMA Pilipinas district was designed with safety in mind as people begin to gather again.

You might also likeRELATED