Sponsored link
Sunday, February 9, 2025

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsCrimeOrganized retail theft is not driving chain stores out of San Francisco

Organized retail theft is not driving chain stores out of San Francisco

Even the retailers admit this. And yet, the media narrative endures.

-

The announcement that CVS would close a store in the lower Haight was met with the usual complaints: Too much retail theft is making it impossible to do business in this city.

It’s a line we have heard over and over again, part of a media narrative that has shifted public policy back toward the failures of the tough-on-crime era that led to massive incarceration, particularly of Black men.

But the reality is that CVS is reducing its retail footprint for business reasons—one of them being that the company now makes a majority of its profits from its insurance, benefits management, and mail-order pharmacy operations, according to Securities and Exchange Commission documents, and has a corporate policy of cutting retail storefronts.

A CVS store in the Castro. Wikimedia Commons image.

In fact, in a pretty stunning report, The New York Times now says that the National Retail Federation can’t defend and had to retract a claim that half of the industry’s $94 billion in lost inventory in 2021 was due to “organized retail theft.”

From the story:

A national lobbying group has retracted its startling estimate that “organized retail crime” was responsible for nearly half the $94.5 billion in store merchandise that disappeared in 2021, a figure that helped amplify claims that the United States was experiencing a nationwide wave of shoplifting.

The group, the National Retail Federation, edited that claim last week from a widely cited report issued in April, after the trade publication Retail Dive revealed that faulty data had been used to arrive at the inaccurate figure.

The retraction comes as retail chains like Target continue to claim that they are the victims of large shoplifting operations that have cut into profits, forcing them to close stores or inconvenience customers by locking products away.

What these giant chains say to the news media—and what the media often reports without much verification—diverts significantly from what corporate executives tell investors.

Classic example, again from the NY Times:

A Walgreens executive said this week that the company, which cited “organized” shoplifting as a reason to close five stores in San Francisco in October 2021, might have overstated the effect of theft on its business.

“Maybe we cried too much last year,” James Kehoe, the company’s chief financial officer, said during a Walgreens earnings call with investors.

Mr. Kehoe also said that the company had “probably” spent too much on security measures and that it might have mischaracterized how much theft took place in its stores.

It was a remarkable admission, retail experts said. Walgreens and other retailers have in recent years complained about an increase in shoplifting, inflaming political debates about crime.

In fact, Walgreens went so far as to hire armed guards in San Francisco stores—which led to the death of an unarmed young trans man.

Somehow, the stories that shows the reality of what happened appear long after the sensational stories that stir up sentiment toward bad political policies. We have seen this for decades. I wonder when my colleagues in the news media will learn.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link

Featured

Trump’s attacks on trans people, public health escalate into a war on reality itself

Administration moves to purge scientific facts, stifle essential research, and erase entire populations.

Juanita More’s Loads of Love party is a Valentine for heavy times

The drag goddess's huge, free V-Day affair shows off the talents of 'our big, amazing, talented, beautiful, powerful family.'

A project almost nobody wants is going forward in the Mission, thanks to Yimbys

60 low-tenants displaced by fire (one dead); now landlord gets to build luxury condos—only because of Wiener and his allies in Sacramento.

More by this author

A project almost nobody wants is going forward in the Mission, thanks to Yimbys

60 low-tenants displaced by fire (one dead); now landlord gets to build luxury condos—only because of Wiener and his allies in Sacramento.

Full board will hear Lurie’s attempt to fire pro-reform police commissioner

Mandelman calls for Committee of the Whole to consider whether to allow the mayor to oust Max Carter Oberstone

Lurie is trying to fire an independent police commissioner; maybe the chief is next

Mayor wants the supes to let him remove Max Carter-Oberstone, one of the best members of the oversight panel, for no good reason except power
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED