Sponsored link
Thursday, July 3, 2025

Sponsored link

Debunking the myth of the poor landlord

 

48hillspoorlandlord

By Tim Redmond

DECEMBER 30, 2014 – If you haven’t heard the one about the poor struggling landlord who has a millionaire tenant with a cheap rent-controlled apartment, then you’re not reading the comments section on 48hills. We are reminded constantly about this sad soul who suffers from the horrors of rent regulation.

But it turns out, as many of us pretty much knew, that this character, like Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny, the 100th Monkey Phenomenon and Spontaneous Human Combustion, is largely a myth.

Yeah, you can always find a counter-example. There are, I suppose, Magic Bullets, and there are probably landlords in San Francisco who make less money than their tenants. Ronald Reagan found a “welfare queen” who had a Cadillac. But they are very much the exception and not the rule.

That’s the conclusion of a new study by the Anti-Eviction Mapping Project, which compares the median income of renters and property owners by census tract in San Francisco.

Let’s take a few examples. In Census Tract 176.01, South of Market, people who owned property had a median income of $111,330 in 2013. Renters had a median income of $17,396.

Let’s move to the Mission, where there are increasingly wealthy renters. Median income for tenants? About $80,000. For landlords? About $154,000.

There are places where it’s close – one Castro/Upper Market district had property owners at $119,000 and renters at $103,000. I found exactly two tracts where the pattern was reversed, one in Portola and one around the Presidio; in those cases, tenants made just a little more than property owners.

But in the rest of the city? Rich areas, poor areas, areas with gentrification, areas with more stability … it’s all the same. People who own property have more money than people who rent.

Now: Median income is of course an imperfect metric. There could be tenants who inherited vast wealth, or made it on their own, who are now retired from working and have lower incomes. There could be landlords who work all the time but have massive debts. There’s always a welfare queen somewhere.

But if we learned anything from the Reagan Era, it’s that you don’t make public policy on the basis of one example. You have to look at the overall data, which shows that most people on welfare are really struggling to get by and don’t own multiple Cadillacs – and most landlords have a lot more money than most tenants.

Rent control makes it possible for people to establish lives and raise families and stay in this city, even as economic changes that have nothing to do with them ravage the affordable housing stock. It keeps the city vibrant and diverse.

And overall, if there’s an impact on wealth, it’s a shift from those who have more to those who have less. Which this country believed in, once upon a time.

 

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram

Sponsored link

Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Latest

BIG WEEK: SF Mime Troupe, Fillmore Jazz Fest, Ant Farm, cheetah croissants….

Plus: Gamelan Seker Jaya, DJ Derrick Carter, Breadbelly's new bake, ancient Greek romance, a drum and bass trailblazer, more to do

What to see at Yerba Buena Gardens Festival this summer ☀️

Celebrating 25 years of free, accessible and artistically excellent programs in downtown SF!

Drama Masks: In ‘Aztlán,’ gripped by intense forces beyond control

Magic Theatre melds carceral to mystical. Plus: Enthralling 'The Last Goat' presents Ancient Greek tale that does much with little.

Screen Grabs: Caught up in the raptors, again

'Jurassic' holiday weekend kicks. Plus: Thomas Kinkaide's secrets, Fraenkel Film Fest, Bill Gunn and Mikio Naruse retrospectives, more.

You might also likeRELATED