Saturday, October 24, 2020
Uncategorized Chevron and big ag are irrigating crops with oil...

Chevron and big ag are irrigating crops with oil wastewater

-

Oil company says the ‘recycled’ waste is perfectly safe. When have we heard that before?

In this ad, Chevron brags about sending oil wastewater to farmers
In this ad, Chevron brags about sending oil wastewater to farmers

By Marc Norton

FEBRUARY 3, 2015 — The San Francisco Chronicle ran a major investigative story on Sunday outlining how nasty waste from the oil industry winds up in Central Valley aquifers.

The story by David R. Baker detailed how state regulators have allowed oil companies in California, particularly in Kern County, to pump wastewater containing “a blend of briny water, hydrocarbons and trace chemicals” into underground water supplies, potentially contaminating water that could be used for drinking and irrigation

But if people in the Bay Area think that this is an issue only for farmers and residents in the hinterlands where oil production takes place, they need to think again.

The toxic effects of the disposal of oil production wastewater may be as near to you as the supermarket or your corner grocery. Here’s why: It’s an open secret that the big corporate agriculture landlords in Kern County are irrigating their crops with wastewater from oil production supplied to them by Chevron.

Do you eat potatoes, tomatoes, carrots, onions or bell peppers?  Do you like almonds or pistachios?  How about oranges, grapes or pomegranates?  Put a little honey in your tea?

Eat any wheat products?

These are all crops that are grown in Kern County, in the southern part of the San Joaquin Valley.

Do you eat beef?  Eggs?  Got milk?  These are also big Kern County agricultural products.

There is a lot of cotton grown in Kern County.  Do you wear any cotton clothes?

And they grow roses.  Makes a nice gift for your sweetie, don’t you think?

In total, Kern County produces over $3.5 billion worth of agricultural products every year, much of it irrigated by wastewater from Chevron’s oil well wells.

Chevron insists that that recycled water is safe, and in fact brags about how wastewater from oil development helps agriculture.

But farmers who live and work in the area aren’t so sure. And given the history of the oil and chemical industry’s environmental safety claims, there’s reason for at least concern.

Touring Kern County

I went on a tour of Kern County on Saturday, December 13. The tour was sponsored by the Center on Race, Poverty and the Environment.  Movement Generation organized the event. We left from Oakland, right by Oscar Grant Plaza, at 7 am, riding in three vans, heading for Delano of Cesar Chavez and the United Farm Workers fame.

Our first stop was the CRPE headquarters in Delano, a modest building near the center of town.  There we were introduced to community organizer Juan Flores, and to Gustavo Aguirre, the CRPE’s Director of Organizing.  Aguirre spent more than 15 years working in the fields, and 10 years working with the UFW.

Soon afterward, we hit the road. One of the first sites we visited was a place where Chevron’s oil operations wastewater is mixed with water destined for the fields.

You can go there, too. It’s right off Highway 99. Take the Highway 46 exit towards Wasco and Paso Robles. Go just a few yards, where you run into an unmarked canal. Drive or hike a little way south on the dirt road there.

Here is Chevron’s wastewater, which runs out of a facility run by Chevron off to the east, where many of the company’s oil operations are concentrated:
48hillschevron1

 

Chevron’s wastewater next flows under a small dirt dam, where it is mixed with clean water flowing in from the south.  Here is where the wastewater flows out from under the dam:

48hillschevron2

The clean water and the wastewater then flows under another dirt dam:

48hillschevron3

…comes out the other side here:

48hillschevron4

…and then flows off towards the fields in Kern County:

48hillschevron5

 

Here is a Google map of the area:

48hillschevron6

The canal coming in from the east carries the wastewater.  This wastewater flows under the small dirt dam, where it mixes with the clean (we hope) water flowing in from the south.  The combined stream of water then flows off to the north under the larger dirt dam, and is used to irrigate Kern County agricultural fields.

Juan, who took us to this site, asked if anybody was willing to take a swim in the water flowing off towards the fields.  There were no takers.

About then a white pickup truck pulled up alongside us, and we decided that it was time to leave.

Open secret

The recent Chronicle article included a quote from Rock Zierman, the chief executive officer of the California Independent Petroleum Association.  “If we’re not able to put the water back [by injecting oil production wastewater it into the ground], there’s no other viable thing to do with it.”

But it is an open secret that Chevron has found another “thing to do with it,” viable or not.

An ad run by Chevron in the 2013 Bakersfield Californian reads, in part:

 “For years, Chevron has been recycling the water that’s produced during our oil recovery process to provide area farmers with a reliable source of clean, local water.  Every day we deliver around 20 million gallons to Kern County’s farms, which helps them grow produce that’s exported all around the globe.”

Chevron even refers readers to a video you can watch about the company’s “recycling” operations. The video ends with the statement that “Chevron has stepped up to the plate.”

Very true.  Your plate, your meal.

Tom Frantz, a Kern County farmer who is featured in the Chronicle article, told 48 Hills that the water Chevron is providing “is still hot and oily when they start mixing or diluting it. We don’t know what toxic or hazardous chemicals are naturally in that water. The salt content is not too high and that is why they think it is ok to use it in a diluted form.

“Poisoning the soil on the surface is the same as poisoning the groundwater in my opinion.  The two atrocities cannot be separated.”

Chevron, of course, admits to no “atrocities” at all.  Cameron Van Ast, a Media Advisor for Chevron, told us that this water “is treated and/or blended to meet the regulatory standards required by the Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board and is also subject to mandatory testing and reporting requirements.”

Apparently, oil companies and regulators think that the toxic mix pumped into injection wells is perfectly safe, too.

Next:  Who is overseeing Chevron’s “recycling” operations?  Is it the same state agencies that have allowed the oil companies to inject wastewater into clean, underground water supplies?

 

Marc  Norton’s website is www.MarcNorton.us.

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

21 COMMENTS

  1. But the plants will not draw from the ground anything that they cannot break down, so I am yet to be convinced that a potato grown in a field with some oil debris in there would be chemically any different from one grown without that.

    You are assuming there is a different but unless you are a botanist and chemist, I don’t see how you can know for sure. It’s just the “yuk” factor at work, sans science, just like the issue with pee.

  2. Urine, harmless (if disgusting), decomposes into harmless substances. Petroleum and drilling waste are poisonous, and do not decompose into harmless substances. The ‘carbon-based’ and ‘plant-based’ and ‘comes from the ground’ arguments are pointless.

  3. Missing my point, which is that items used as or in dirt or compost do not necessarily make any plants growing there harmful.

    Example: peeing on compost that is used to fertilize food is very different from peeing on the food itself.

  4. Have you considered opening an all carbon-based restaurant? On the menu:

    — Poison Oak salad with urine dressing
    — Red tide soup
    — Aged chicken tartare with gasoline dressing
    — Swollen can surprise
    — Hemlock cocktail

    Sam, persuasive as ever, should not have any problems convincing the health department.

  5. Ugh. OTOH, why is it that SF has more water rights than the Central Valley? That is a bigger question, and it is just wrong that SF has more water rights than the breadbasket of the world.

  6. Are you saying that there is clear irrefutable evidence that a little oil in the ground means that anything grown there instantly gives you cancer?

    I’d be fascinated to see that evidence and also your qualifications in interpreting that data. Don’t hold back now.

  7. so what if oil comes from the ground – oil and it’s by-products cause wonderful things like leukemia and other cancers

  8. The organization that gave Norton the tour probably should have collected samples of the blended irrigation water. Also it would be a good idea to test produce from crops that use this for irrigation.

    Are they certified organic? I used to worry only about pesticides, but this article and the one Sunday in the Chronicle suggest our oil economy is doing much more than just polluting the air.

  9. You pee on the compost and the compost goes on the vegetables.

    The point being that you can put all kinds of unpleasant stuff in the ground and the vegetables won’t harm you.

  10. oil is carbon-based and derived from vegetation

    So are strychnine, sarin, ricin, and Zyklon B. I’m sure those are all perfectly safe natural substances, nothing to worry about!

    I hear they can really spice up all sorts of dishes, you should definitely try them.

  11. Uric acid as fertilizer on plants, now that is a truly ignorant statement. But hey, then it DOES follow that we use crudeoil and byproduct chemicals in our food production.

  12. Hmm, let’s see, oil is carbon-based and derived from vegetation. So the objection here is using carbon-based waste to fertilize carbon-based crops?

    did you know that peeing on vegetables helps them grow? Or did you think that was disgusting?

    It’s all natural. There are a million things I worry about more than this.

More by this author

Fear — and hope — for journalism

So many bad things happening to local news media -- which is why we are trying to make a difference.

Another big-money anti-tax front group emerges in SF

The Chamber of Commerce and GOP donors have created Fed UP SF to attack progressive taxes.

Holding the SF cops accountable

Plus building on toxic waste sites and the legacy of Alex Nieto ... that's The Agenda for Oct.18-25

The big GOP and real-estate money moves into District One

Fake tenants group and big outside cash is now trying to promote Philhour over Chan in a race that could determine the balance of power on the board.

GOP-linked big money attacks progressive candidates and taxes in SF

Millions in PAC money from the 1 percent -- and big Mitch McConnell backer -- floods into San Francisco for last-minute hit pieces.

Most read

Best of the Bay 2020: City Living winners

Best Street Fair, Best Salon, Best Politician, Best Tour, Best Hotel, Best Trainer, more in our 2020 Readers' Poll

Best of the Bay 2020: Arts & Nightlife winners

Best Art Gallery, Best DJ, Best Drag Queen, Best Arts Festival, Best Nightclub, and more in our 2020 Readers' Poll

Best of the Bay 2020: Food and Drink winners

Best Burger, Best Sushi, Best Burrito, Best Dive Bar, Best BBQ, more in our 2020 Readers' Poll

Best of the Bay 2020: Shopping winners

Best Bookstore, Best Bike Store, Best Shoe Store, Best Cannabis Dispensary, more in our 2020 Reader's Poll

Róisín Murphy buffs her disco-house crown on gliding ‘Róisín Machine’

The Irish diva showed us who she was through momentously silly quar performances. Her latest album affirms her mastery of the nocturnal club beat.

The end of Shahid Buttar’s campaign — and the lessons

Shahid Buttar’s campaign against Rep. Nancy Pelosi was always a longshot. He was challenging the person most responsible for challenging Donald Trump, and while...

Wiener tries to look progressive in debate

But that requires a bit of historical revisionism, since his record has always been very moderate on police, housing, and homelessness.

Our Best of the Bay 2020 Readers’ Poll winners are here!

Thousands voted—here are the results of our 45th annual readers' choice awards.

Screen Grabs: Borat’s ‘totally sensationalized false account’ and other bombshell releases

Sure, it has Giuliani looking suspect—but is 'Borat Subsequent Moviefilm' any good? Plus, a new documentary on the grifters leading the alt-right movement, and 'The Guardian of Memory.'

Good Things: Andrew Ashong and Kaidi Tatham bless the studio—plus more new releases to soothe

We rounded up the most relaxing beats in the known new music universe. SunPalace gets a 2020 remix pack, a new sad banger from Mac DeMarco and Benny Sings, more.

You might also likeRELATED