Sponsored link
Saturday, July 12, 2025

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsCrimeBreed announces budget cuts as Dorsey plays the 'cops tax' card in...

Breed announces budget cuts as Dorsey plays the ‘cops tax’ card in campaign

The city has a $1 billion budget problem, and only a total tax overhaul will fix it.

-

Mayor London Breed made an announcement today that demonstrates the deep problems with the move by Sup. Matt Dorsey to lock police spending into the City Charter.

But the more conservative Democrats are trying to use the bogus concept of a “cop tax” to change local politics.

Dorsey wanted to guarantee funding for 2,300 officers, a prospect that would cost as much as $300 million a year.

His measure was amended to link that goal to a funding source—something that Dorsey and others have described as a “cop tax.”

Sup. Matt Dorsey says new funding for police is a ‘cop tax,’ but there’s no way to fund his proposal with existing revenue except with radical cuts to other services.

But Breed just announced a series of preliminary cuts that will get much, much deeper as the city faces what could be a $1 billion deficit.

I have asked Dorsey what existing services he would cut to add $300 million to the police budget. He’s usually pretty responsive to the news media, including me, but he never answered that question.

And now the whole “cop tax” thing is going to be a big issue in the spring elections and in the supes race. Dorsey, who is part of a more conservative slate running for Democratic County Central Committee, sent out an email today including this:

I meant every word of my 2022 campaign slogan, which committed to keep “fighting for a Safer San Francisco” — including the word “fighting.” In fact, you may have seen that once again over the last week as I’ve stood up to an obstructionist Board of Supervisors majority whose cynical “Cop Tax” scheme is delaying needed progress on police recruiting and public safety imperatives. I’m not backing down on fulfilling the promise of a fully staffed police department, and you can expect to hear more from me and my allies about that soon.

But to make progress on everything we’re trying to accomplish, San Francisco will need the full partnership of a strong, effective and unapologetically mainstream Democratic Party.

The problem is that the Police Department is only part of the city’s public-safety system, and much of the rest is also deeply underfunded.

More than that, the city has an existing tax structure based so deeply on downtown real estate that in the next year or two, we need either to radically overhaul the way we raise revenue (including new taxes, not just for cops but for all basic services) or face dramatic and crippling cuts.

Never mind the reality, though: The concept of a “cop tax” is going to be a talking point for the Right in San Francisco this spring. We are already seeing that happen—and we are not seeing the major news media do anything to counter it.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

Featured

Britney blackout: Author Jeff Weiss relives the ’00s pop culture cataclysm

Music journalist's gonzo new book 'Waiting for Britney Spears' dives into the tabloid-strewn wreck of the schlocky decade.

Under the Stars: Madlib’s sonic crystal ball spins again

Plus: Kendra Morris scores a reggae-tinged 'Flat Tire,' Jay Som rocks back with 'Float,' Directions in Stereo dips into the wax stacks

Good Taste: An obsessive early guide to the Outside Lands food multiverse

Fun bevs, free samples, fries as meals, super splurges, and more: It’s not too soon to plan your festival menu.

More by this author

Will supes oust one of the most effective members of the Homeless Oversight Commission?

And what does this say about the mayor and the board changing policy on Prop C and 'housing first?'

Supes to vote on Billionaire Budget deal amid protests over housing money

Plus: A crackdown on RV parking that will make more families homeless, and will the Police Commission do a real national search for the next chief? That's The Agenda for July 6-13

Wiener-Newsom CEQA ‘reform’ is a dangerous fraud

Lithium battery factories without environmental review. Miami Beach development along the coast. And it's not going to make housing more affordable
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED