Sponsored link
Thursday, February 22, 2024

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsSupes to decide if 16 and 17-year-olds should vote

Supes to decide if 16 and 17-year-olds should vote

What would be the impact if local youth could vote? Think: High School democratic clubs

There are plenty of reasons why San Francisco should lower the voting age to 16, but the most important one is that young people need to get involved in politics and their communities, and voting is a habit that starts early or not at all.

Some critics argue that teenage brains aren’t well enough developed to make important judgements, like who ought to be on the School Board and the Board of Supes.


But it’s hard to argue that the adults who vote for some of the people who have been elected in this city have that wonderful cognitive judgment, either. Lots of voters don’t pay attention until the last minute, and are overly influenced by ads and slick campaigns. If everyone who voted was on top of their game, the billion-dollar political consulting industry wouldn’t exist.

So let’s get off that track for a moment and talk about what might happen if we extended the franchise, just for local races, to High School juniors and seniors.

The candidates for School Board would have to talk to students at the schools. That almost never happens now. Why talk to the people whose educations you control, when they can’t vote for you?

The candidates for supervisor and Community College Board would have to talk to young people, too – and be respectful, and deal with issues that the youth of San Francisco face every day.

More important, there would be political clubs for youth. There might be a Lowell High School Democratic Club, or a Gateway High School Democratic Club, or even better an SF High School Students Democratic Club. There would be young people joining the Milk Club, and Alice, and the Sierra Club, and the neighborhood clubs.

All of those groups would have to reach out to youth, because young people would be their future.

We would hear a lot more talk about what teenagers care about and need in the city (and trust me, I have two teens who have been well educated in the public schools, and they won’t be opposing limits on sugary drinks). Politicians will have to deal with student debt, with police abuse (how many young men of color trust the SFPD?), with the lack of after-school programs … and a lot of other things that aren’t on the agenda today.

And some of the kids who join the High School Democratic Club – not just to debate and talk, but to make actual endorsements that matter, and to evaluate candidates who will have to show up and meet with them – will become tomorrow’s civic (and state and national) leaders.

The high school kids I know are not easily impressed by adults. You think the current supes would have an easy time getting away with scripted messages at a club dominated by 16 and 17-year-olds? Then you aren’t hanging out with those young people in this city.

At any rate, this comes before the Board of Supes tomorrow afternoon. If six members vote for it, the issue will be on the November ballot. There will be a rally at City Hall at 4pm, and the hearing starts at around 5pm. For more info, go to vote16sf.org.

And I will be very, very interested to see which supes vote against this.


48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

Sponsored link


Three of Breed’s police commissioners suddenly reverse on racist pretext stops

Bizarre excuses as commission votes 4-3 to limit traffic stops that have no public safety value

Good Taste: Food names you can trust

Louie’s Original, Barbara’s Fish Trap, and more Bay Area places named after people worth knowing.

Screen Grabs: High-tail it to ‘Hundreds of Beavers’

Hilarious and chewy. Plus: Jewish Film Institute Winterfest animates Ann Frank, James Baldwin scathes US

More by this author

What the billionaires want

The agenda behind the big money is clear—and for more than 40 years, it's been a massive failure that created most of our social problems.

Ten groups. $33 million, half of it dark money. Behind the billionaires in SF politics

New report sheds light on the massive influx of right-wing money trying to buy votes.

SF cop fires gun out the window in Santa Rosa. Cops fail on internal affairs reviews

Plus: Reviewing the Valencia St. bike lane, are there enough mental-health treatment beds ... and what's up with Wiener's new attack on CEQA? That's The Agenda for Feb. 18-25
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED