Monday, May 17, 2021
News + Politics Opinion Government of the rich, by the rich, and for the rich

Government of the rich, by the rich, and for the rich

OPINION: Plan Bay Area 2050 is about growth at all costs, including massive displacement, to help the wealthy get even wealthier.


 Editor’s note: Plan Bay Area, a joint effort of the Association of Bay Area Governments and the Metropolitan Transportation Commission, is creating a “blueprint” of strategies to guide growth in the region in the next 30 years. Comments were due Monday; here is one of them.

The most important single piece of information iin the thousands of pages of the Plan Bay Area 2040/50 planning process is a chart buried on page 69 of PBA 2040’s deeply buried “Final Equity Analysis Report” Supplemental Report, which is now not any part of the PBA 2050 package:

It tells us that in 2017, when the report was prepared, 32 percent of lower-income households in central-city communities identified as “Communities of Concern” were at risk of displacement.

And – of great and terrible significance – it shows that none of the proposed PBA 2040 Alternatives reduced that risk appreciably, one would make it much worse, and doing nothing would be catastrophic!

Since then MTC and ABAG, which are running the planning process, have done … Nothing.

And the accompanying Map 42 of the Communities of Concern – even further buried all the way back on the second-to-the-last page of this buried Supplemental Report – shows the devastating situation right now.

It’s devastating even though, due to some statistical gerrymandering, the definition for “Communities of Concern” already makes them much smaller than the truth. And the definition of “low-income” utilized is an absurdly low “twice the national federal poverty rate” which is itself far below the otherwise-standard definition of 80 percent of SF Bay Area Average Median Household Income. In other words, the situation is far worse than this chart depicts.

None of this concealment of the bitter outcomes of Plan Bay Area for lower income residents is accidental or inadvertent.

There is no mystery at all what the real priority and prime motivation for Plan Bay Area 2040/50 has been and will be: Growth At Any Cost – even the human costs of forced displacement, de facto ethnic cleansing, and cultural genocide of central city communities – to continue to manufacture great wealth for the Elite of the Bay Area and provide for the Professional Class/White Collar Workforce that supports it. 

The best counter-measures Plan Bay Area 2040/50 has to offer to reduce such harms are the classic neo-liberal nostrums of utterly inadequate ‘trickle down’ economic benefits via increased public revenues from Growth and – maybe – more funding for affordable housing development through increased sales taxes on the people of the Bay Area – but never the wealth or the properties of the Elite of course!

Plan Bay Area 2040/50 is social and economic injustice codified – and disguised, of course, with endless ineffectual platitudes proclaiming disingenuously their good intentions and empty “Principles.” 

But in truth this is Government of the Rich, By the Rich, and For the Rich. 

There is only one genuine and realistic “Equitable Future” path forward for a “Sustainable Future” for the people of the San Francisco Bay Region:

  • Balanced Economic/Affordable Housing/Community Building Growth (for example, the combination of San Francisco’s Proposition E Balanced Growth Initiative approved by SF Voters in March and the Central Soma Plan adopted by the City in 2018).
  • A 21st Century Tax Revolution so that the wealth of the Bay Area finally funds all the urban, environmental, and social Infrastructure that in truth makes it possible – including housing for all the people of the Bay Area (for example, the proposed Split-Roll Property Tax Reform on this November’s state ballot – and no more sales taxes ever!)

Our city, our Bay Area, our state, our nation, and our world are all now in the greatest crisis since the end of the Second World War. But today, the enemy is not an Axis or even a virus. The enemy is ourselves – our selfishnesses, our greeds, and our blindnesses that refuse to admit the consequences of our addiction to Growth and instead to put People First before Wealth.

Plan Bay Area 2050 could – and must – be the start.

John Elberling is manager, Build Affordable Faster California


  1. Welcome to Pelosi’s world! At this point, you guys aren’t victims; you’re volunteers. I’m planning my escape from California. Guarantee that I won’t be here in 5 years. I am far from alone.

Comments are closed.

More by this author

Progressives are winning the Battle of San Francisco

The powerful moderates -- and their financial supporters -- lost overwhelmingly in the Nov. 3 election.

Epic Sacramento showdown over looming eviction tsunami

In an important State Capitol legislative shift, on Thursday Berkeley Assemblymember Nancy Skinner agreed to amend her controversial housing bill, AB1085. She said she will...

Government of the rich, by the rich, and for the rich

 Editor's note: Plan Bay Area, a joint effort of the Association of Bay Area Governments and the Metropolitan Transportation Commission, is creating a "blueprint"...

The real legacy of SF’s planning director

Editor's note: The Chron yesterday presented its report on the record of John Rahaim, who ran SF's City Planning Department for the past 12...

Should the Dems impeach Trump — next summer?

I’m amazed by the crummy tactical thinking of progressive pundits about the impeachment of Trump. Their commentary and reporting these days on cable news...

Most read

Opinion: AIDS denialism in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame?

In 2000, the Foo Fighters embraced the kind of anti-science thinking we still see today. It's time they apologized.

Not one dollar of state rent-relief money has arrived in SF

Hundreds of millions in federal funding is available -- but tenants aren't getting it.

Big Telecom giveaway bills head for state Assembly votes

Plus: Measure to limit CEQA appeals goes before supes and a rally to limit supportive housing rents. That's The Agenda for May 17-23

What happened to Halston? New doc dives deep into designer’s story

In Halston, the new biopic about the visionary American fashion designer, director Frédéric Tcheng makes every effort to remain objective when portraying the contentious...

Can people paying rent for a parking space be evicted for living in cars?

Caltrans is about to try to remove people from a lot under I-80.

You might also likeRELATED