Friday, April 16, 2021
News + Politics SF supes to hold hearing on school reopenings

SF supes to hold hearing on school reopenings

It's a complex issue and even close allies disagree -- but there's a lot of agreement that Mayor Breed isn't helping.


The Board of Supes is holding a special hearing Tuesday/22 on the School District’s plans to reopen public schools.

It’s a topic so heated that it has some traditional allies at odds as families continue to scramble to deal with that could at this point be more than 12 months without in-person public education.

Sup. Sandra Lee Fewer wants to know what the School District needs to re-open.

Everyone agrees that’s a serious problem, particularly for younger kids and for students of color in low-income communities.

There’s also substantial agreement that Mayor London Breed has not done enough to bring everyone to the table and find a solution.

“It’s the power of the Mayor’s Office to bring people together,” Sup. Sandra Lee Fewer told me. “And she hasn’t done that.”

The district and the United Educators of San Francisco haven’t yet reached an agreement on the conditions of reopening. The district had set a Jan. 25 date for opening a few schools for a few students back. Although some news media reports say the sides are at an impasse, talks are continuing – although not over the holidays.

School Board Member Alison Collins told me that “our plan for re-opening relies on us reaching an agreement with our labor partners, and we haven’t reached that agreement. We’re still negotiating.”

Susan Solomon, president of the teacher’s union, told me the union is still working with the district on negotiations (although both sides are taking a break for the holidays). “We are not at an impasse,” she said.

The union’s demands are almost entirely based on safety. They want good ventilation is all classrooms, PPE and training for all teachers and staff, and regular testing for all teachers and for students whose families request it.

(UC San Diego is partnering with the public schools in that city to do quick, easy tests; UCSF could do that too, but so far that isn’t happening.)

The union also wants small, stable cohorts of students and teachers who can work with appropriate distancing, health and safety plans that comply with CDC, Cal-OSHA and state Department of Public Health standards, and safe and reliable transportation for students, teachers, and staff.

The biggest sticking point, though, is probably the union position that the schools shouldn’t open until San Francisco is back in the Orange – or “moderate” tier for COIVD infections. The city is currently in the Purple, or Widespread Risk tier.

The Board resolution, sponsored by Fewer, a former School Board member, states:

There is strong consensus amongst public health experts, including Dr. Fauci and CDC Director Redfield, that schools can operate in person learning in a safe and responsible way, and opening schools should be the highest priority for any jurisdiction … New recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control place high priority on keeping schools open, from kindergarten through 12th grade, saying schools should be both “the last settings to close” and “the first to reopen” because of the critical role they play in providing meals and support services to children.

A Dec. 19 statement from the district’s unions says that :

Since the beginning, SFUSD set an example by closing down ahead of state mandates and, in doing so, it saved thousands of lives. Now is the time for SFUSD to continue this kind of leadership. We all want to reopen but we cannot do so in the midst of uncontrolled community spread. In fact, school districts around the Bay Area have determined that schools cannot safely reopen while in the purple tier.

A lot of San Francisco schools are old, and have smaller classrooms, and Collins told me “there just isn’t room” in many facilities to return many students with adequate social distancing. “Bret Harte has plenty of space,” she said. “Carver does not.”

To reopen, some students would have to go to different schools than they have attended in the past, possibly with different teachers, she said.

Fewer told me that these are exactly the sorts of problems the city can help address. “We have the ability to make resources available. There is empty city property that could be used for classrooms. But there is no plan to bring back more than a small number of kids.”

Fewer said that the district has told her “we can’t open because of this, and we can’t open because of that, but what I haven’t heard is: We could open if you gave us these resources.”

Collins said that district staff have offered some suggestions, but she is putting together her own list of the resources that the district needs.

In the middle of all of this, the new interim head of the Labor Council, Kim Tavaglione, went on Facebook to attack Fewer and Sup. Hillary Ronen, who is a cosponsor of the resolution, saying:

I think it is despicable that any politician is criticizing educators and faculty of school districts for the schools not opening. They sit in their ivory towers being safe while criticizing others for caring about their safety. It’s unfair and not true. All workers should have the absolute right to bargain their own safety. And for a politician to criticize that they should pack their bags and leave the city.

Fewer and Ronen are, by any standard, among the most pro-labor people who have ever served on the Board of Supes. They both worked to make sure that city workers got their contracted raises this year, even in a pandemic budget crisis – and they have faced huge political hits for doing that.

So I have to say, whatever side you are on in the debate, this isn’t helpful.

“Why are we dividing ourselves?” Fewer asked.

Solomon told me that the union is not opposing the Fewer resolution. “We have bigger issues, like getting the schools back open,” she said.

She also said that the mayor had not reached out to UESF; Breed has been happy to blast the union, but “she has made no effort to talk to us. I have not received a phone call. It’s really frustrating – I am willing to meet with anyone to get this solved.”

I would bet the mayor could also call UCSF and ask for help with testing.

As Ronen put it: “As the adults can’t get it together to figure it out, the kids are suffering.”

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.


  1. You know you’re dealing with a SF union person when if you dare to disagree with them on one thing you are ordered to “pack their bags and leave the city. ”

    No wonder so many of the teachers I know say they are afraid of their union – I used to think that was so odd that so many people reported being afraid of the union, but I’m now seeing why.

    The same labor leaders seem okay with learning hubs and YMCA centers being open , but those employees don’t matter cause they don’t pay the union money?

    Safety is important, but I don’t understand why the unions are fine with their employees flying in airplanes, and tutoring for extra money and putting themselves at risk for COVID, but say they can’t go into SFUSD because they are scared of COVID when they aren’t afraid of COVID in other venues. There are public school teachers sending their own kids into private school and learning pods, but they just can’t make it into work themselves cause COVID is so dangerous. Either everything should be shut down, or schools should be open. Can’t have it both ways. If it’s safe for private school kids and teachers to go to school, then it’s safe for public schools. No double standards, and stop saying private schools have more money, cause they don’t.

    I’m not a big fan of London Breed’s policies, but she’s right on this one.

    Fauci and The National Union President have said schools should be open, so if SFUSD can’t find a way, they need to start refunding the excessive parcel taxes.

  2. Another b.s hit piece on Breed.

    As “richmondman” has pointed out, neither the Mayor (unfortunately) nor the Board of Supervisors has any control over the public schools –which, of course, is the responsibility of the Board of Education (BOE).

    The BOE has, once again, massively failed in their charge.

    After receiving wholly justified grief for their full-speed-ahead not-mission-critical school renaming and mural white-washing fiascos — rather than focusing on making certain that public education functions during the pandemic — the BOE huffilly responded that they can “do two things at once”.

    Well, apparently they can’t and both SF kids and their parents continue to suffer.

    Last Spring and early on in the Covid crisis, when the BOE had a chance to be pro-active with regard to getting remote learning up and running for the coming fall term, the BOE not only dithered, but turned down free/donated funds to pay for a online learning consultant because, at some point the consultant had consulted for charter schools , (i.e., the “enemy”.)

    Accordingly, the BOE did nothing — at least nothing substantive/effective.

    So this is where we are — fecklessness + political posturing bickering and pettiness = utter failure by the BOE.

    Knock it off with the Breed hit pieces and place the blame where it squarely belongs — at the feet of the BOE.

  3. “Fewer and Ronen are, by any standard, among the most pro-labor people who have ever served on the Board of Supes. They both worked to make sure that city workers got their contracted raises this year, even in a pandemic budget crisis – and they have faced huge political hits for doing that.”

    By any standard, merely feeding SEIU when it makes demands is pro labor. Check.

    Meanwhile, Latinx working people are left to their own devices, deprived of income support and forced to be expendable workers. It seems that the pro-labor folks want to make teachers into expendable workers too.

    The dynamic here is that some heteros can’t stand one more minute with their little monsters at home and underfoot. Other heteros would never dare take the risk to expose their offspring to being infected by the larvae of strangers. Once the district and teachers iron out their differences, they will have to deal with the much more powerful dynamic than mere work condition negotiations.

  4. Blame Breed, but no mention of the lack of leadership at the Board of Education.
    Typical. Tim can’t bear to criticize the real problem. Marc Norton. Failure and fired as a teacher, faiiled and fired as an administrator. Now the President of the Board of Education.
    The man behind the effort to remove Abraham Lincoln’s name from San Francisco schools.

Comments are closed.

More by this author

Breed won’t promise to spend real-estate tax money on rent relief

The voters approved Prop. I last fall to support tenants and affordable housing, but the mayor says she will use the money for her own priorities.

Reese Erlich, foreign correspondent and radical reporter, is dead at 73

After a life of progressive politics, ground-breaking journalism, and social activism, a legendary writer loses battle with cancer.

There’s a lot more to the GG Park debate than cars v. bikes

This is part of a huge discussion the city needs to have about transportation -- and equity -- in a post-COVID world.

SF could have affordable Internet for everyone for $35 a resident

Why isn't the Breed Administration moving for municipal broadband? That's The Agenda for April 11-18

A new move to get corporate money out of state political campaigns

AB 20 would ban contributions from corporations to any candidate for state office in CA.

Most read

Radical right group is trying to attack public-sector labor in SF

Anti-union mailers are going to workers home addresses -- but really, this group is looking pretty desperate.

How To Reopen Nightlife: Enough with the boys’ club, make room for women

DJ femmelectric and promoter Alex McGeagh speak about equity, access, and safety for women and nonbinary folks.

Black Freighter Press sails in, boosting writers of color and radical imagination

The revolution will be published, with the help of SF Poet Laureate Tongo Eisen-Martin and Alie Jones' new outlet.

City College students fight back against brutal faculty cuts

Firing teachers could also mean the end of a lot of treasured programs.

Breed won’t promise to spend real-estate tax money on rent relief

The voters approved Prop. I last fall to support tenants and affordable housing, but the mayor says she will use the money for her own priorities.

You might also likeRELATED