Wednesday, January 20, 2021
Uncategorized Breed tries to derail Campos tenant-protection bill

Breed tries to derail Campos tenant-protection bill

-


Despite a tenant-heavy district, Sup. London Breed is seeking amendments that would undermine a tenant-protection bill

 

By Tim Redmond

APRIL 3, 2014 — The legislation by Sup. David Campos that seeks to increase relocation fees for Ellis Act evictions was continued Tuesday, after a hearing on the Google Bus Program ran really late.

But in preliminary discussions on the issue, it became clear where the battle lines are drawn – and where the big fight will be April 8.

Sup. London Breed – representing the tenant-heavy District Five – wants to amend the bill to carve out an exemption for all landlords who are 55 or older, own one building, and have owned it for more than 20 years.

Her argument: There are some small landlords who see their buildings as their retirement fund, and if they’ve been renting at low levels for long periods to time, a significant part of their investment could go to pay the relocation fees.

Those people are not speculators, she said.

But Sup. Jane Kim put that in perspective. There’s no law against selling a building, and there’s no mandate that anyone pay any fees at the point of sale. If a longtime landlord wants to sell and retire, fine: Nothing in the Campos bill would have any impact on that.

Breed’s answer: Well, yes – but you can get more money for a building if you sell it vacant.

In other words, as Kim put it, a real-estate speculator tells a longtime homeowner to clear out a building so the homeowner, not the speculator, takes the rap and handles the fees of the Ellis action.

Sup. Norman Yee offered a milder form of the Breed amendment, suggesting that the Rent Board take into account the age of the owner and the length of ownership before deciding on the hardship.

And Sup. Scott Wiener continued his concern over the language in the application a landlord has to file to ask for a hardship, an issue that he brought up in committee and pushed the Rent Board on repeatedly. His concern: Landlords now have to fill out what he called an invasive form that requires them to list not only their cash on hand and property but their personal possessions, furnishings, clothing, and jewelry.

Tenants have a simpler form.

The rent board director made it clear that the agency didn’t actually force landlords to itemize their clothing and furniture, but Wiener wasn’t satisfied. He wanted an amendment deleting that language from the Rent Board hardship form. Nobody objected.

But Breed will find some allies for her proposal – and if she gets six votes, it will directly undermine the intent and impact of the Campos legislation.

The vote will also put the more centrist supervisors who want to get progressive support on the hot seat: Breed, Sup. Malia Cohen, and Sup. David Chiu all voted in favor of the Google Bus Program, infuriating tenant, labor, and environmental advocates and putting them directly on the side of the tech industry in the Battle for San Francisco.

Chiu, who is running for state Assembly against Campos, and Cohen, who has a serious challenge in her district, can’t afford to alienate the tenants two weeks in a row.

Kim, who is a co-sponsor of the Campos bill, told me Tuesday that she didn’t expect it would face major opposition. But Breed stirred up enough trouble to delay the bill a week.

It will be a major test.

Marke B.
Marke Bieschke is the publisher and arts and culture editor of 48 Hills. He co-owns the Stud bar in SoMa. Reach him at marke (at) 48hills.org, follow @supermarke on Twitter.

10 COMMENTS

  1. New political era, derived from no other, Londontown where many frowns around town due gentrification. Simply, the marginalized policies going benefit political career of Londontown puppet for Mr.Lee plea justice lies. 30,000 BMR” units anyhow: London you veto and disrupted many housing measures western addition, Hunters Point guess influence Ed and Rodney Fong not privatize neighborhoods for development. Expect reward London 2020, mayoral or senate keep dreaming only acknowledge you antics Ed fight is among city hall where fair housing? Awaiting welcoming next economic influence of effort “San Francisco” Londontown is dream odd seems housing repeal soon decision
    leased to supporters whom?

  2. Well, Charles, that’s just WRONG! Considering that we’re supposedly a diverse, tolerant non-racist city. Of course, I don’t think that’s really true unfortunately, but that’s how San Francisco “sells” itself and it’s image to the rest of the world.

  3. I didn’t vote for Breed, I wanted Christina Olague to remain in office. Breed’s too centrist for my taste, Olague would have been DIRECTLY on the tenant’s side, no question.

  4. If an landlord has owned a building for over 20 years in SF, they are going to make out just fine. The building is worth many times what they paid for it. These were exactly the types of concerns that were raised by Breed’s opponents when she was elected.

  5. Oh, the poor old landlords, what’s to become of them? These people really make me sick. How about having some concern for tenants for a change; they’ve almost all got less than landlords.

More by this author

Oakland’s As You Like It label rises from promise to musician Johnny Igaz

10 years in, the party crew launches platform to support Bay Area artists—inspired by member gone too soon

Still broke and roasted at 40: a lightning round with Broke-Ass Stuart

How many times has this media mogul eaten at French Laundry? We ask the tough questions before his celebrity birthday roast.

Historic coalition of local independent publications aims to Save SF News

15 community outlets band together for monthlong fundraiser to keep producing essential journalism. Donate now!

A gonzo guide to great gifts (that will help local spots survive)

Everything you need: unique art, mouthwatering chocolates, radical guidebooks, nifty clothes, and brave women of color

Party Radar: Epic 3-day festival aims to Revive the Nightlife

All aboard this star-packed, fundraising online party train—it's time to save independent local dance floors.

Most read

SF COVID vaccine: Sign up to be notified when you’re eligible

Find out via email or text when you can contact your health provider (or public system) to get vaccinated.

Taxi drivers, disability-rights advocates oppose new Market St. traffic plan

Plus: UC Regents vote on huge new project -- and Willie Brown's Chronicle column will quietly disappear. That's The Agenda for Jan 19-26

Newsom budget hurts environmental justice programs

Shouldn't utilities -- not communities of color -- be paying for better fire prevention?

Bay View editor may take legal action against private prison company

Keith Malik Washington charges that the Federal Bureau of Prisons and the Geo Group retaliated after he contacted a reporter about a COVID outbreak in a halfway house.

You might also likeRELATED