The San Francisco budget blew up this week as moderate allies of Mayor Ed Lee pushed through a plan without progressive support.
Late this afternoon, as all of the progressive supes were out of the office and many City Hall staffers had left for the Trans March and the beginning of Pride Weekend, the Budget and Finance Committee, with a bare quorum, passed a budget that the progressives haven’t even seen.
That sets up a potential battle at the full board and the prospect that the mayor’s allies will ram it through without progressive votes.
For the past ten years, every city budget has passed with little or no dissent.
Sup. Malia Cohen, who chairs the Budget Committee, said the budget is something that “takes care of our most vulnerable.” Sup. Katy Tang said the budget was something all 11 supervisors should be proud of.
But that’s not what’s happening: I am told there is no consensus, no deal, and at this point it appears there may be five votes against the plan.
That would be highly unusual – by the end of the process, when the budget goes to the full board, it typically gets overwhelming support.
“Out of respect for Pride, I asked not to do budget negotiations today,” Sup. Hillary Ronen told me. “But apparently they didn’t want to wait for their colleagues. I haven’t seen what they voted on.”
Ronen said she had heard the committee found more money, and she said she’d be happy to get back to work Monday and try to reach consensus. But the deal that Cohen and the Mayor cut this afternoon did not involve any progessives supes.
Cohen initially tried to bring together aides from all 11 board offices to try to reach some sort of compromise on how to cut from the mayor’s proposal and fund other priorities.
The staffers have been meeting almost around the clock for the past few days, and some of the supes have joined in.
By Thursday, the progressives were getting mostly nowhere. Efforts by Sup. Aaron Peskin to cut what he saw as bloated spending in several areas (including an expensive expansion of the police command staff and expected salary savings) to shift money to more social services were shot down by the majority on the Budget and Finance Committee.
Then late Thursday evening, with some of the progressives saying they can’t support a budget that doesn’t devote more money to human needs, particularly housing and homeless services, Cohen invited Peskin to join her in the Mayor’s Office to try to reach a compromise with Mayor Lee.
But Peskin told me when he got there, the mayor’s staff wouldn’t let him in. “It’s pretty unprecedented, the way this mayor is doing things,” Peskin said.
The mayor’s spokesperson, Dierdre Hussey, told the Examiner’s Josh Sabatini, who has been doing great reporting on this, that the mayor only meets with the chair of the Budget Committee, although in past years that hasn’t been the practice.
This afternoon, the committee was supposed to meet at 12:30, which was postponed to 3:30, and finally began work at a little after 4.
At the time, none of the progressive supes were around or participating. Peskin had taken himself off the Budget Committee (which, with Sup. Norman Yee out of town, had to meet with only three members, a bare quorum).
There was no reason this had to happen today, on the eve of Pride, with a rush-job final budget that many of the supes involved in the negotiations had never seen.
The whole situation – in a year when the city has plenty of money – is a reflection of an unpopular lame-duck mayor with a new chief of staff, a Budget Committee dominated by the mayor’s allies and a board majority that seems to have little interest in taking on the mayor in the name of compromise.
Sup. London Breed showed up to say the she was “disappointed” that the two other members of the panel weren’t there. But Norman Yee had a prior engagement and Peskin decided that there was no point in continuing.
There are millions of dollars for vulnerable populations at stake, but considering the amounts we’re taking about, it’s hard to believe that the mayor wasn’t willing to give a little.
Instead, seven years into an administration that was supposed to usher in a spirit of compromise, he has further divided the city.