Sponsored link
Thursday, October 29, 2020
Sponsored link
News + Politics Elections Democrat in D7 race helps pay for Republican candidate's mailer

Democrat in D7 race helps pay for Republican candidate’s mailer

Joel Engardio is on a one-two slate with right-wing GOP hopeful -- and the mayor is now endorsing both Engardio and Myrna Melgar.


The race for D7 supervisor took some interesting turns this week with Democratic candidate Joel Engardio paying for a place on Republican Stephen Martin-Pinto’s mailer and Mayor London Breed adding an endorsement of Myrna Melgar.

Breed has already endorsed Engardio, who is running one of the most conservative campaigns for supervisor, even from that district, that we’ve seen from a credible candidate in years.

Stephen Martin-Pinto is running a right-wing GOP campaign — and Democrat Joel Engardio is helping pay for his mailing.

Engardio is all about “clean streets, less crime, and better services.” He supports neighborhood schools (which means, in San Francisco, segregated schools.) He wants to see big cuts in the city budget.

Martin-Pinto says he will have “zero tolerance for crime, drug-markets, needles, fesces and litter.” He wants to “slash fees, regulation and taxes” and hire more cops.

Engardio apparently thinks that the GOP voters who like that approach will vote for him as a second choice.

Engardio told me:

Let me start first by saying that I’m a proud Democrat, I worked to advance civil rights at the ACLU, I served on the leadership committee for the SF Democratic Party, and I wholeheartedly support Biden/Kamala.

As you know, campaign finance rules clearly state that you have to pay for any communication that features you, or you risk triggering an independent expenditure. Stephen Martin-Pinto chose to feature me on a mailer, so I paid my share of the mailer. … Stephen has been an active member of our neighborhood. He’s been the president of the Sunnyside Neighborhood Association. We disagree on a lot of things as members of different political parties, but I think it’s important to work with other people in your neighborhood.”

So there you go: A “proud Democrat” paying to help put out a right-wing Republican mailer.

Melgar, who has some significant progressive support, just announced that Breed is also backing her:

“I’ve had the distinct privilege of working with Mayor Breed as President of the San Francisco Planning Commission, and I am so honored to have her support in my campaign for Supervisor.” 

Melgar was not a Breed appointee; she was put on the commission by the Board of Supes. But it’s clear that the mayor at this point is looking to defeat Vilaska Nguyen at all costs, and while she initially favored Engardio, she is willing to see Melgar elected.

Breed has been lashing out at the progressive majority on the board, and the endorsement suggests that the mayor believes Melgar will not be as direct a challenge to her agenda as Nguyen would be.

But Breed, like many recent San Francisco mayors, doesn’t seem to have a lot of influence over voter decisions. She opposed Prop. C and the voters approved it. She worked hard to get Vallie Brown elected supe in D5, and the voters went with Dean Preston.

Not sure how much difference this is going to make – except that polling I’ve heard about suggests that Engardio has a slight lead, with Melgar and Nguyen essentially tied a few points behind. If Melgar and Nguyen share each other’s second-place votes, that could put one of them on top.

And Breed would rather have Engardio than Nugyen.

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.


  1. I find it problematic that Myrna Melgar was Avalos’ Treasurer for his Mayoral campaign. A campaign which was cited by the SF Ethics Commission for bad record keeping regarding finances- her job. She had no experience at a job like that- and it showed.
    She willl not be any of my choices.

  2. Our schools are racist racist racist segregated. I don’t have kids because of my rhombus shaped vagina but even though I am not a parent and can’t ever be one because I have a very shrill voice and I have a condition in which my skin smells like lentil soup, I will dictate to parents how to raise their kids becase I have a PhD in Social Justice and Victimization Studies. People need to shut up when I speak.

  3. Community schools are better for the students and especially the parents/guardians on many measures, but mostly involvement. The quality of the schools is a management issue, not one of geography or race of the attendees. We should be putting the focus on empowering the students and their families to demand accountability and on helping get good teachers (the main ingredient) and the school district to hire those good teachers.

  4. Steven Pinto is a right wing nut who wants clean feses free streets. He is a total fascist. His opinions are dangerous and he must be silenced. In San Francisco we do not believe in hate speech.

  5. Engardio ran Ron Conway’s Astroturf group SF Moderates, and ran in 2016 on up zoning the entire city. He’s a con artist but we have short memories.

  6. “Engardio is all about “clean streets, less crime, and better services.” He supports neighborhood schools (which means, in San Francisco, segregated schools.) He wants to see big cuts in the city budget.”

    How would the be any more segregated than they are now? If more Asians in the Bayview would go to schools in the neighborhood, they would be less segregated. The way out is language programs.

  7. Melgar was appointed by Ed Lee which is, like, totally different than London Breed. Ed Lee was Chinese and London Breed is Black. Ed Lee was a man and London Breed is a woman. Totally different.

    “The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which.”

Sponsored link

More by this author

Big Money’s racist attacks in D7

Plus: School Board members of color get threatening online messages. Is this really San Francisco in 2020?

The biased coverage and real story around Lowell High and school renaming

Attention Chronicle: A lottery for the 'elite' school is neither new nor a radical idea -- and neither is discussing changing the names of schools celebrating racists and colonialists.

State billionaires saw vast windfall since COVID

While millions suffer, 161 rich people take in $312 billion -- and nobody in Sacramento seems to care.

Fear — and hope — for journalism

So many bad things happening to local news media -- which is why we are trying to make a difference.

Another big-money anti-tax front group emerges in SF

The Chamber of Commerce and GOP donors have created Fed UP SF to attack progressive taxes.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED