Sunday, February 28, 2021
News + Politics Holding the SF cops accountable

Holding the SF cops accountable

Plus building on toxic waste sites and the legacy of Alex Nieto ... that's The Agenda for Oct.18-25


The San Francisco Police Department has implemented only a fraction of the reforms that the Obama-era Justice Department proposed. Despite that, the city is working behind the scenes with the Police Officers Association – which is by far the largest obstacle to reform – on a significant raise for cops.

SF police are way behind on reforms.

The full Board of Supes, acting as a Committee of the Whole, will hear testimony from the chief and other witnesses on the progress toward reform – and the public will also be able to weigh in. That item is scheduled for 3pm (although it will probably be much later because there are other 3pm hearings ahead of this one.)

One of those – if it goes forward, and a lot of land-use appeals get continued – involves the question of whether the city should allow and encourage development, particularly housing development, on sites that have toxic waste issues.

In this case, it’s 1776 Green Street, where a developer wants to build six market-rate (that means luxury) condo units on a site where a gas station or auto repair facility has operated for about 100 years.

At one point, records show, there were several fuel-storage tanks below ground. As was often the case in the era before strict environmental laws, they leaked. The soil has benzene contamination at 900 times the acceptable levels for human exposure, appeal documents filed with the supes say.

Benzene is a human carcinogen. It’s also just nasty stuff that you don’t want to be exposed to.

But the Planning Department says the project can go forward without an environmental review, citing a “common sense” rule. (Common sense to me says you don’t build housing on a toxic waste site.)

This project is particularly relevant since the Chron, in a rare example of excellent investigative reporting, showed in August that the city has ignored environmental considerations in its desperate efforts to allow new housing on old gas station sites.

The Sierra Club, among others, has written to the supes arguing that this project needs a full environmental review.

The supes will also vote on a measure by Sup. Matt Haney that would prevent the mayor from giving a department head full authority to approve contracts. That, of course, stems from the Department of Public Works scandal involving Mohammed Nuru. The late Mayor Ed Lee gave Nuru extraordinary powers to approve contracts, and Mayor London Breed continued that authorization, which now has the FBI crawling all over City Hall.

Sup. Shamann Walton has a measure that would make it unlawful to call 911 or in other ways contact the cops with the specific intent to discriminate against a person “on the basis of race, color, ancestry, ethnicity, national origin, place of birth, sex, age, religion, creed, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, weight, or height.”

I have to wonder: If this had been in place five years ago, would Alex Nieto still be alive?

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.


  1. The supes did not cut one single SFPD sworn officer in this budget and are now teeing up a hand-wringing session over the DoJ recommendations followed by a likely pay raise.

  2. leftcoaster: It’s on Tuesday the 20th.

    You can search under “SF – Committee of the Whole – Update on Findings and Recommendations Regarding Law Enforcement Practices”.

Comments are closed.

More by this author

Denmark, taxes, happiness, racism …

... plus saving the SIP hotels, cracking down on serial permit scofflaws, and more problems with private prisons. That's The Agenda for Feb. 22-28

SF can buy housing for thousands of people, now.

With federal and local money, taking over hotels would cost a fraction of the price of building affordable housing.

New documentary exposes COVID crisis at private SF prison

Adachi Project film shows the inside story of virus outbreaks -- and the Geo Group's failure to contain them.

So San Francisco isn’t broke. Where is the money?

What if we tried to attract artists instead of tech companies? Hearing will look at post-COIVD economy. Plus: A huge payout to victim of police abuse. That's The Agenda for Feb. 15-21

We can reimagine the post-COVID San Francisco

The future should be up to us -- not the corporate overlords who have controlled city planning for decades.

You might also likeRELATED