Sponsored link
Tuesday, June 15, 2021

Sponsored link

UncategorizedOn Michael Brown, Sketch Factor, and Finding a Safe...

On Michael Brown, Sketch Factor, and Finding a Safe Way Home

Michael Brown was shot by the police on his way home
Michael Brown was shot by the police on his way home

By Julia Carrie Wong

There is a deep and disturbing dissonance between the Ferguson Police Department’s demands that protestors “Just go home,” and the reality of Black life in America.

Ferguson is the suburb of St Louis, Missouri where Michael Brown, an 18-year-old Black man, was shot and killed by a police officer on Saturday afternoon. He was on his way home to his grandmother’s house.

Trayvon Martin was on his way home too, after getting a snack. Renisha McBride was trying to find her way home after getting in a car crash. Oscar Grant was on his way home from a New Year’s Eve party, taking public transportation. Amadou Diallou was unlocking the door of his own apartment building.

None of them made it home.

The cruel irony of a militarized police force demanding Black youths to return home while blocking their way and menacing them with tear gas, “less-lethal” weaponry, and tanks has been repeated over and over in American history. From the kidnapping of African peoples, to chattel slavery, to the failure of Reconstruction, to sharecropping, to redlining, to urban renewal, to the War on Drugs, to sub-prime mortgages: Our country’s history is one of uprooting Black people, of forcibly denying them a home, and then of punishing them for being without one.

Over and over again, Black people in America have uprooted themselves, have moved north or east or south or west, between neighborhoods or cities or states or countries, seeking a better situation where they can live lives of dignity, free from racist terror. Over and over again, they’ve been met with rioting white people, some wearing hoods, some wearing police uniforms, some wearing no special uniform at all.

Help us save local journalism!

Every tax-deductible donation helps us grow to cover the issues that mean the most to our community. Become a 48 Hills Hero and support the only daily progressive news source in the Bay Area.

Donald Harry, a resident of Ferguson, was speaking to the Washington Post’s Wesley Lowery outside his house on Monday evening when police threw a tear gas canister into his yard. “I’ve got my family in here,” he told Lowery.

Later, the reporter came across a 23-year old Black man crying: “He said he was walking home when officers approached him and sprayed tear gas in his face and peppered him with rubber bullets.”

A reporter from the St Louis Riverfront Times witnessed Rich West, a 24-year old Ferguson resident, standing in his own yard with his hands up in the air: “’This my property! This my property!’ he shouted, prompting police to fire a tear gas canister directly at his face. He moved at the last second.”

I had originally planned to write this column about a new app, SketchFactor, that has gained considerable press attention for its ill-advised launch as a crowd-sourced mapping tool for users to report and share incidents of “sketchiness” in cities. The app is supposed to provide walking directions for users to find a safe route home.

Co-founder Allison McGuire tried to pre-empt criticism that her app was designed to validate and reinforce white fear of people of color in an interview with Crain’s New York:

“We understand that people will see this issue,” Ms. McGuire said. “And even though Dan and I are admittedly both young, white people, the app is not built for us as young, white people. As far as we’re concerned, racial profiling is ‘sketchy’ and we are trying to empower users to report incidents of racism against them and define their own experience of the streets.”

She failed. SketchFactor’s website was later updated with a complaint (since removed) that reporters had failed to contact the company for interviews prior to criticizing it. I requested an interview and was told by McGuire “Thanks for your interest in SketchFactor, but unfortunately we’re not accepting any new press at this time.”


SketchFactor is not a new idea and it’s not a good app. Like many crowd-sourced databases, it falls victim to the rule, “Garbage in, garbage out.” Most of the reports I’ve read on the app are either racist or trolling garbage.

There’s much to be said about the way this kind of map-based application can become a tool, not for white people to avoid certain neighborhoods, but for white people to more easily gentrify those neighborhoods – a process that inevitably leads to the displacement of people of color from the communities they’ve established. The mapping of white discomfort and fear can become a tool for real estate interests to collude with law enforcement to “clean up” communities of color.

We’ve seen this happen in San Francisco, where the people of color who hang out at 16th and Mission are being driven out by increased police presence, drummed up by the “Clean up the Plaza” campaign undertaken by people with ties to the real estate developers interested in remaking the neighborhood with luxury apartments. 16th and Mission is the quintessential “sketchy” area. For SRO residents, it’s an open air living room. For the white gentrifiers, it’s “dangerous.”

This is the same dynamic that led to the death of Alejandro Nieto, a 28-year old Latino man who was shot and killed by San Francisco police while eating his dinner in Bernal Heights Park on March 21, 2014. Numerous calls to 911 were made that evening by people who apparently found the presence of a brown-skinned man eating a burrito in the neighborhood he grew up in threatening. After arriving on the scene, police shot at Nieto more than a dozen times. One of those bullets killed him.

SketchFactor is not an app for Black people. If it were, it would help Blacks and other people of color avoid, not each other, but the armed forces in every city in America that shoot and kill with impunity. Instead, it’s another source of data for an increasingly militarized police force bent on terrorizing Black people and other people of color, and for the corporate interests that profit from their displacement.

But SketchFactor is just one minor example in an entire system of white supremacy. It will probably go away soon, and we’ll still be left with a country where young men like Michael Brown can be gunned down trying to find their way home.

This afternoon, people will gather in parks and plazas across the country at 4:00pm Pacific to hold a National Moment of Silence in honor of the victims of police brutality. In San Francisco the event will be at Civic Center; in Oakland at Frank Ogawa Plaza.

(h/t @ShrillCosby for the link to the Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture’s African American Migration Experience)

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.


  1. Thanks Sam. You do not need to use an apostrophe when pluralizing condos.

    Some condos are new units, and if you study the housing situation in San Francisco, you’ll also know that condos are often created out of older structures that are divided up into smaller private units. These units that are built out of older units do displace people when the owner decides to kick out renters in order to sell. So yes, a person who buys a condo can in fact displace someone if the condo was built on or out of an existing older unit. The word “condo” does not mean that there was nothing at all in the space before.

    As for facts getting in the way of my reverse racism, that would seem to indicate you believe I hate myself for being white. Is that what you meant to say? Wikipedia: Reverse discrimination is discrimination against members of a dominant or majority group or in favor of members of a minority or historically disadvantaged group.

    I certainly don’t hate myself. Please don’t worry about me Sam.

  2. Condo’s are new units and so someone who buys one hasn’t displaced anyone, by definition.

    Still, don’t let facts get in the way of your reverse racism.

  3. Interesting examples h0mee. I’ll bring them up the next time I’m at brunch in the Mission with my friends who have bought condos there and have displaced the land’s former Latino residents. I’m sure they’ll appreciate these examples because they all happen to be ASIAN AMERICAN. Oops. Complexity. Contradiction. #mindblown

    I am a firm believer in white privilege and the “white discomfort” Julia writes about, I just think the racial and class politics of San Francisco are getting more and more complicated and it’s intellectually dishonest not to talk about it in those complex terms.

    As for EVERYTHING else Julia wrote. I couldn’t agree more. 110%. We need to disarm our police. Make sure people of color don’t get assasinated by bigoted white cops just for walking down the street and most of all we need a radical redistribution of wealth and power so that every kid of every color can grow up with the same opportunities. We need a tax of 100% or more on condos that displace people and an END to the Ellis Act evictions.

    Finally, this comment: “I don’t usually do this but… dammit mike brown… that’s your white supremacy talking.” is just absurd. Don’t even know what point you were trying to make… My admitting to a situation being complex is me not being an idiot, my white supremacy comes out in other ways, mostly when I’m shopping.

  4. That’s an interesting viewpoint Fazal. When you refer to “whiter parts of town” are you referring to Pacific Heights? Marina? Because I have a hard time seeing how these communities are better served by MUNI coverage. I’m not saying that I don’t see your point, only that I don’t have the information to validate your assertion.

    Also, my main point is that trying to talk about the situation in SF in terms of “white privilege” versus the circumstances facing “people of color” is an entirely over simplistic assessment of the case in SF. I truly liked a lot of what Julia had to say in this article and I think it would be better served by a more nuanced perspective on race and class in this city.

  5. I beg to differ man, sorry for the callout man, I don’t usually do this but… dammit mike brown… that’s your white supremacy talking. What about all the old chinese women that don’t speak english living off of begging or scraping trash cans. What about the thriving vietnamese community, not wealthy by any stretch in the TL. Just the other week I met a queer desi on the streets in the mission, runaway from his family asking for directions. Just because you aren’t plugged in to these communities in the city doesn’t mean they don’t exist.

  6. For an allegedly liberal city, SF has a dark history of racism (anti-Chinese in the 19th Century, anti-Japanese during WWII and the ethnic cleansing of the Western Addition by Justin Herman) and the sordid level of neglect for Bayview-Hunter’s Point is an absolute disgrace.

    @Nick: one way to measure a minority’s clout is by how many resources get allocated to them. Just see how inadequate Muni coverage is in Chinatown or the Sunset/Richmond compared to whiter parts of town.

  7. The paragraph on “white discomfort” seems not to ring true in the case of SF. Anywhere else and I might not have read that and cringed, but in SF, you can’t talk about “people of color” and pretend that the Asian American community faces the same disadvantages as Black and Latino folks. You can try, but it doesn’t reflect the reality on SF streets.

Comments are closed.

Sponsored link

More by this author

Help is on the way — but many tenants don’t know about it

Phone bank seeks to find people eligible for rent relief who may not know it's available or how to apply. Here's how to join.

Supes clash with parks director over role in private organization’s ‘threats’

Ginsburg waffles when asked if he knew of and approved a Parks Alliance letter that the supes agreed was 'outrageous' and 'unacceptable.'

The Chron has a Mission business story all wrong (are we surprised?)

There are very real issues of displacement and racial equity in the debate over moving a tech-centered 'destination' to 14th and Mission.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link
Sponsored link
Sponsored link
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED