Saturday, October 24, 2020
News + Politics Why we disrupted the Police Commission

Why we disrupted the Police Commission

How doctors see the afflictions of institutionalized racism and police violence


On Wednesday May 18th, members of UCSF’s Do No Harm Coalition and White Coats 4 Black Lives chapter interrupted the San Francisco Police Commission meeting with a simple request. As doctors, nurses, and students, we believe it is our ethical duty to stand up for the health of our patients and the communities in which we serve. We also feel a moral obligation to oppose policies and actions that are in violation of human rights.

Medical professionals and students supported the hunger strikers in their demands for police accountability

It was in this spirit that we asked the Police Commission to respond to the demands of the community by putting the issue of police department leadership and accountability on the agenda. Community members had made this simple request at many previous meetings, only to have the commission ignore their demands or recess their meetings. Following in this pattern, instead of responding to our simple request, the president of the commission voted to adjourn the meeting early–despite dissent from one commissioner–and the commissioners left the building.

The following morning, on Thursday May 19th, an SFPD officer shot and killed Jessica Williams, a young African-American woman, in San Francisco’s Bayview district. Later that day, Greg Suhr was finally forced to resign after 22 police killings under his watch. In some senses, Suhr’s resignation was a victory, as a core community demand had finally being met; at the same time, as health care providers, we could not ignore the tragic cost of yet another human life. In that moment of conflicting joy and sorrow, we were reminded that this is the beginning, not the end, of the struggle.

San Francisco is facing the twin public health crises of institutionalized racism and police violence. As trainees and providers, we see how racism, discrimination, income inequality and displacement play out in the very real lives of our patients. When Jessica Williams was shot, she was taken to San Francisco General Hospital, where all of us have trained and two of us will be practicing as physicians beginning this summer. Our profession charges us with the great responsibility of protecting human life; to us, the loss of Jessica Williams’ life, and others like hers, is not an abstract concept.

Beyond our professional duties, each of us feels the pain and suffering in San Francisco on a personal level. All three of us were born and raised in the Bay Area, two of us in San Francisco itself. We are committed to the health and well-being of the communities that helped raise us; we cannot stand idly by as these communities suffer trauma, violence, and hate inflicted by those charged to serve and protect them. While we each followed our own distinct path towards medicine, we share a unifying purpose–the belief that health does not begin or end at the walls of a hospital, and that it is our duty to create communities in which we can all live safe and healthy lives.

San Francisco’s twin afflictions were not cured with Suhr’s resignation. The Police Commission members have shown us that they are not accountable to the people of San Francisco, and the problems within the SFPD go far beyond the chief. It is time for all sectors of society to stand on the right side of history. We call on our colleagues–doctors, nurses, students and other health professionals–to join this movement to end systemic racism and impunity for police violence. We need to support real visions for how to make our communities safe and healthy for ALL.

Joshua Connor, MD, MPH, Olivia Park, MD candidate, and Yakira Teitel, MD, MPH are members of USCF’s Do No Harm Coalition



More by this author

Most read

Best of the Bay 2020: City Living winners

Best Street Fair, Best Salon, Best Politician, Best Tour, Best Hotel, Best Trainer, more in our 2020 Readers' Poll

Best of the Bay 2020: Arts & Nightlife winners

Best Art Gallery, Best DJ, Best Drag Queen, Best Arts Festival, Best Nightclub, and more in our 2020 Readers' Poll

Best of the Bay 2020: Food and Drink winners

Best Burger, Best Sushi, Best Burrito, Best Dive Bar, Best BBQ, more in our 2020 Readers' Poll

Best of the Bay 2020: Shopping winners

Best Bookstore, Best Bike Store, Best Shoe Store, Best Cannabis Dispensary, more in our 2020 Reader's Poll

RĂłisĂ­n Murphy buffs her disco-house crown on gliding ‘RĂłisĂ­n Machine’

The Irish diva showed us who she was through momentously silly quar performances. Her latest album affirms her mastery of the nocturnal club beat.

The end of Shahid Buttar’s campaign — and the lessons

Shahid Buttar’s campaign against Rep. Nancy Pelosi was always a longshot. He was challenging the person most responsible for challenging Donald Trump, and while...

Wiener tries to look progressive in debate

But that requires a bit of historical revisionism, since his record has always been very moderate on police, housing, and homelessness.

Our Best of the Bay 2020 Readers’ Poll winners are here!

Thousands voted—here are the results of our 45th annual readers' choice awards.

Good Things: Andrew Ashong and Kaidi Tatham bless the studio—plus more new releases to soothe

We rounded up the most relaxing beats in the known new music universe. SunPalace gets a 2020 remix pack, a new sad banger from Mac DeMarco and Benny Sings, more.

Screen Grabs: Borat’s ‘totally sensationalized false account’ and other bombshell releases

Sure, it has Giuliani looking suspect—but is 'Borat Subsequent Moviefilm' any good? Plus, a new documentary on the grifters leading the alt-right movement, and 'The Guardian of Memory.'

You might also likeRELATED