Wednesday, November 25, 2020
News + Politics Scenes from a bizarre police response to a peaceful...

Scenes from a bizarre police response to a peaceful protest

Welcome to Super Bowl week: Mario Woods protest shows heavy police presence near the NFL's Super Bowl City


It’s Saturday, January 31, and protesters are gathered at Union Square to demand justice for Mario Woods, following a call from Justice for Mario Woods Coalition.

48hillswoodsprotest1At 11 am, dozens are gathered to bring attention to the case amid strong police presence. Today’s protest is one of the many actions planned ahead of the Super Bowl celebrations to bring attention to growing civil rights issues in the city, most importantly the Black Lives Matter movement and the growing number of homeless people in the city.

Although Mayor Ed Lee made headlines calling for a federal investigation of the Woods shooting, Daniel Landry, activist leader with the Justice For Mario Woods Coalition, says that’s not enough.  “We are gathered here today as a peaceful protest to demand justice” he says “We want Ed Lee to understand that justice can only come if there’s trust between the people, the officials, and SFPD.”

San Francisco police are still expected to handle the homicide case and determine whether charges are warranted for the officers who killed Woods,  a step protesters staunchly oppose. “Lee’s request means nothing, this is yet another antic,” Landley remarks.

Amy Farrah Weiss, Founder of Neighbors Developing Divisadero and former mayoral candidate, addresses the crowd: “Last year, at Martin Luther King Day, Ed Lee hosted a screening of the film Selma and while addressing the crowd of young African American children he urged them to demand change. At his inaugural speech he asked to be judged by his actions. It is time for us to demand action, it is time for us to hold him accountable.”

48hillswoodsprotest3Chants ensue. “What do we want? JUSTICE, when do we want it? NOW.” Hundreds of police officials gather around Union Square and Powell Street, an odd sight when only a few dozen protesters try to make their way towards Market street.

Just as the rally is about to begin, Felicia Jones, leader with The Mario Woods Coalition, takes the mic and urges: “We must protest peacefully, we must show our strength and respond to the murder of Mario Woods by a firing squad.”

Demands are repeated as the crowd begins to move, “Our demands are simple: Fire Chief Suhr, indict the officers involved in the killing of Mario Woods and conduct an independent investigation into the incident.”

By now the crowd is more than 200 strong. There are dozens of people representing different causes. In the corner, Luma Michael, 63, is giving away flyers for an event to honor black lives. “It is important that everyone stays together, that we all protest and stand up for people of color. This needs to stop, the targeting of homeless people and of people of color this must end,” she says. Beside her a volunteer from the Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment, ACCE, is giving away vibrant yellow “We Won’t Go” badges.

Chants grow stronger: “Indict, convict, send the killer cops to jail. The whole damn system is guilty as hell,” and as the rally crosses the entrance of the Powell BART station, dozens of passersby join in while others document the protest through their mobile phones. A man in his 70s shouts back at the crowd: “Get Ed Lee, Fire Ed Lee.”

As the rally enters Market Street, police start to blare sirens and announcements begin: “Please clear the roads, get on the sidewalks, anyone blocking the road will be arrested.” Several protesters stop and shout back, “Whose streets? our streets!” The crowd is now more than 400 strong, and as police cars move in, someone in the crowd mentions that the riot police have blocked entrance to Super Bowl City, which is open for the first day. The news does nothing to dampen the momentum.


A few minutes later, the protesters are head-to-head with the riot police. Some quickly move to the sidewalk while others stand in front of the police wall, facing batons. “You should join us too,” a protester says, trying to engage with an officer, who doesn’t bat an eyelid as the crowd continues to chant “No justice, no Super Bowl.” An organizer moves forward to stop an angry protester from shouting at police officials: “Stop, do not do this, we will all get beaten up, just stop”.

Felicia Jones moves quickly through the crowd to speak to an officer who would identify himself only as K. O’Sullivan. “You cannot stop us from a peaceful protest” Jones says; the crowd did not receive any orders for dispersal, and no one from the police department got in touch with the organizers.

O’Sullivan is determined. “We made several announcements through the loud-speaker,” he says. “This rally is not permitted. You are welcome to continue on the sidewalk but you can’t walk on the roads.”

Jones is not satisfied. “Is this the color of my skin? because there’s many protests and marches that happen here all the time and you don’t stop them. Is it because I am black?”

O’Sullivan quickly withdraws from the conversation “All right now, I am stepping back. As I said, you are welcome to walk down the sidewalks but you can’t walk on the roads. This is a dispersal order,” he says.

Jones not one to give in easily “You are herding us, like one herds animals. Like you killed Mario Woods as if he was an animal,” she says as she moves back to speak to her the organizing team.

Instructions from the organizers come quickly and are on point: “We are here to make a statement and we made a strong statement. We are here to say that we demand justice, that we will keep coming back until our demands are met. We are peaceful. So we request everyone to come to the sidewalk, do not do anything violent and we must not be arrested.”

The organizers ask everyone to remain peaceful and to get rid of their placards before entering Super Bowl City. The crowd disperses into small groups into side streets, and it doesn’t take long for the police to block Mission Street as well, this time with even more police officials in riot gear blocking all entrances on both ends of the streets.

Minister Christopher Muhammad, of the Nation of Islam, is the one to speak to the police now. He’s quick and effective; the police agree to let protesters march to Super Bowl city to a public event, but only if they walk through a police corridor.

It’s a bizarre sight, as hundreds of police officials march on both ends of a small group of protestors. A group of black teens starts to join, but turns away for another route after looking at the heavy police presence.

It’s not long before tourists in their NFL jerseys start snapping photos as some remark “So many police officials for a handful of protesters.” And for an event that is open to public. Nevertheless, as the crowd enters Super Bowl city, with police officials on each side, it’s apparent they are not giving up. If anything, they’ve already made their presence felt at the grand opening of the NFL’s big hype event. “We won’t go away, we will haunt you, haunt you in your sleep” the chants faint as protesters disperse.

It could be a sign of things to come.

Sana Saleem
Sana Saleem is a writer with a focus on social justice and human stories. She's member board of advisory for the Courage Foundation, Edward Snowden's legal defense fund.


  1. If I really have to tell you, they just shut down the entire Bay Bridge, for one. In other areas of the country there have been riots around anti-police brutality marches. In SF, a number marches have turned to into riots. How does the SFPD know what this particular group is going to do, and why would they assume it is ‘just march peacefully’?

  2. Just because the Giants fans rioted, does not mean the BLM protestors do not riot, or take over the bridge. And I actually did criticize those fans who did that. It just would have seemed sort of random to bring it up, as it was not the subject at hand. You are really out of line.

  3. what do they do? They calmly march, carry signs and ask to be acknowledged. I admire their wise tactic to get notice by blocking the bay bridge, or a BART station or the four million dollar super bowl party that is free to the NFL.Someof that money could have gone to Mr. Wods family for his murder by cops, eh?

    This as a peaceful events and only the cops acted like it was not. A military presence is not appropriate response to a peaceful and constitutional demonstration. Geez, those pigs at the Oregon wildlife refuse didn’t get penns in by cops for weeks and weeks of freeloading power, ploughing nature preserve land, stealing federal government cars, etc. but these people walk down the street and the are corralled like animals.

  4. You failed to address the Giant fans who mobbed, burned a bus, had many fights and damaged other property. Do you only criticize black peaceful demonstrators? You are just projecting ‘fights and damage, for there was no fighting, no damage, at this peaceful demonstration. Effective comments are responsive to the actual facts, not just inflammatory, bigoted rhetoric — made up rhetoric.

  5. If I really have to tell you, they just shut down the entire Bay Bridge, for one. In other areas of the country there have been riots around anti-police brutality marches. In SF, a number marches have turned to into riots. How does the SFPD know what this particular group is going to do, and why would they assume it is ‘just march peacefully’?

  6. It is a bizarre response. What do you see the protesters do? I see them carrying signs, marching and chanting in unison. They certainly aren’t Giant fans who mob around drunkenly, get in fights and damage property.

More by this author

Garcia Zarate gets time served — but won’t go free

Jose Ines Garcia Zarate, the undocumented homeless man whose trial became a national issue, was sentenced to three years in prison on Friday in the death...

Firearms expert says Steinle killing fits pattern of an accident

The bullet that killed Kate Steinle fit the pattern of an accidental discharge, a firearms expert testified today in the murder trial of Jose Ines Garcia...

Zarate looked confused, disoriented during police interrogation

It was confusing, often contradictory, as the jurors today heard the interrogation of Jose Ines Garcia Zarate, an undocumented homeless man accused of killing...

The Steinle crime scene: The gun, the shirt ….

San Francisco police Officer Scott Hurley is trained to discover evidence or explosives suspected to be underwater. But on July 2nd, as he felt through...

Zarate: Intentional killer — or confused and mentally ill?

The prosecution in the trial of Jose Ines Garcia Zarate tried to set the stage for the day Kate Steinle was killed, presenting witnesses...

Most read

Nancy Pelosi just announced her retirement

Rep. Nancy Pelosi cut a deal that will put her in the position of House speaker for four more years (assuming the Democrats retain...

Why it matters that Boudin is charging a cop with manslaughter

The DA's unprecedented decision sends a message that the police can't kill people with impunity.

Will the cops agree to an acceptable deal by next week?

POA and Mayor's Office still in secret talks with Dec. 1 deadline for final approval of a new contract.

Why did so many people vote for Trump?

Radical economic inequality causes social breakdown. We're seeing it right now.

You might also likeRELATED