Sponsored link
Sunday, September 26, 2021

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsWhy corruption matters

Why corruption matters

The sleaze at City Hall undermines public faith in government -- at a time when the future of humanity depends on it.


The latest round of the evolving City Hall scandal doesn’t involve massive embezzlement. It doesn’t involve public employees pocketing public money. The cash amounts involved in the alleged bribery are in the thousands of dollars, not even the tens of thousands of dollars.

And of course, nothing has been proven in court.

Mohammed Nuru and Harlan Kelly were part of the “city family.”

But this ongoing culture of corruption is making me sick.

I was on a radio show years ago with Willie Brown, after he was out of office, and comedian Will Durst, and the set was in a hotel on the waterfront, and there was a new piece of public art out the window that apparently some folks were upset about, since it had been placed there with no public process.

“That looks like something I would have done,” Brown said with a big smile. Laughs all around.

The message: When Brown was mayor, he didn’t care about the rules – he did what he wanted to do, just to get thing he wanted done, and now we can all joke about it.

But it’s not funny.

Here’s the thing: One of the reasons our society is so badly messed up right now is that a whole lot of people have no faith in government. They don’t believe that government is a solution; they think it’s a problem. That’s how Ronald Reagan got elected, and we are still suffering from that hangover – it’s the entire basis of the Trump Phenomenon.

But we are facing two existential crises right now – climate change and economic inequality, and they are directly connected.

If we can’t solve the climate crisis, humanity could go extinct. And there is no way to solve that without government action. We can all drive electric cars and stop eating meat and travel less and buy less plastic crap and ban natural gas in new housing and ride our bikes and do so many other things that are so important – but in reality, individual action isn’t going to be anywhere near enough. Not in the US, not in the world.

This crisis requires collective action, meaning regulations, standards, and enforceable rules that require not only individuals but big corporations to change the way they operate.

It will require governments around the world, starting with the US, to say: We can’t live like this anymore. It will require a Green New Deal and a lot more.

We collectively can do this without putting people out of work and without economic damage. But we can’t do it without government.

Meanwhile, the level of economic inequality in the US (and other parts of the world) is already creating massive social unrest. It’s unsustainable; our economic (and political) systems can’t survive if we keep going in this direction.

The person who best understands and explains this is Thomas Picketty, the brilliant French economist. His book, Capital in the 21st Century, makes clear that all of the neo-liberal and conservative ideas – including investing in education and training for the “jobs of the future” – are nowhere near enough to stave off disaster. The only thing – the ONLY THING – that will work is taxing great wealth.

That means governments around the globe acting to take money away from the very rich, most of whom make their money not by working but by leveraging their wealth to create more wealth, and redistributing it to the rest of society (so, for example, people who work in oil fields and coal mines can maintain their standard of living after we shut down those industries).

And the only way either of these things can happen, and my kids can live in a stable, habitable world, is if most of us are willing to believe in government.

Right now, I look around at people I know and they say: Government is corrupt. Look at Mohammed Nuru. Look at Harlan Kelly. Look at how easy it’s been for people with big money and connections to game the system in San Francisco.

And look at how long this has been going on, and how nobody in the Mayor’s Office has done anything about it.

What do the major players here have in common? They were appointed to their jobs by Willie Brown or Ed Lee, who was appointed to his job by Willie Brown.

(Oh, and look at the mayor and the governor having a fancy meal at a restaurant none of the rest of us could afford when we are all supposed to stay at home. It’s not the $350 dinner. It’s the message.)

If Mayor London Breed knew about how her friends and political allies were operating, and looked the other way, then she was at worst encouraging it and at best enabling it. If she didn’t know anything, that’s a massive management failure.

Nobody in the mainstream news media or the political world has yet called her on that. I get it – the mayor and the supes and everyone else is busy trying to keep the residents of SF alive during COVID. But at some point, someone has to ask the question:

How many members of the “city family” knew about or should have known about this, and when are they going to be accountable? When are we all going to say that all this corruption, even if it seems small-time,  matters – big time – because it destroys the faith in government that is critical to our future as a species and our ability to avoid economic collapse?

Or are we all just going to do business as usual, again?

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.
Sponsored link


  1. richmondman,

    Enjoy this while you can as will I.

    First thing Kamala will do after the swearing in is to fire David Anderson.

    He’s getting too close to Willie and he’d roll over on her like a Walter Wong to stay out of a ‘Deliverance’ repeat in prison.

    Am I the only one actually enjoying all of this intrigue, national and State and local?

    And, Kamala did lots of good work in this town.

    She’s also pure machine bred and is not dumb.

    Y’all remember when President Truman took time off to go to the funeral of Boss Pendergast in Missouri?

    Same kinda thing here and there is some level of ‘honor among thieves’.

    She’s gotta protect Willie and what’s left of her City Hall ‘Family’.

    Go Warriors!


  2. I’ve learned that one way to spot likely corruption is when outcomes repeatedly defy any reasonable rationale, interests who have no business with a contract get it, interests whose operations don’t make much headway continue to get funded, etc.

    Brown’s political operation and successors clearly deliver outcomes that fit this profile.

    Progressives also participate in the process that leads to these outcomes. The votes on SFPD defunding and MOU over the past few months fall into this category, as if the progressive supervisors were serving interests other than those of the citizenry.

  3. Yup. It stinks, and it is not surprising at all. Willie Brown prides himself on just doing exactly what he wanted and Devil take the hindmost. His system of political patronage (which includes Kamala Harris, whom I support) was run in parallel to the actual government and look at the end results. Bent pols serving themselves DESPITE huge annual salaries, benefits and all the trimmings. And their takings were so petty: Were they valued as tokens of fealty? Certainly not for their monetary value.

    The only solution is to follow through with conviction for these petty crimes. That will amount to slaps on wrists. The real punishment is that according to PERS rules they can (and should) be fired for their malfeasance and stripped of their pensions. That is the real harsh. Put a few of those canceled pensions on pikes in front of City Hall and it will be a generation before some career politician clown lets a developer take him on a family vacation.

  4. One correction that should probably be made to the author’s reasoning is that the corruption that was finally brought to our attention by the FBI almost certainly came out of complaints that were filed with federal agencies by anonymous local parties with inside knowledge years ago. Whistleblowers were not able to file complaints with local authorities for fear of retaliation, due to the lack of protection for whistleblowers. This problem could be solved with new legislation that protects whistleblowers. Perhaps this is something the City Attorneys may want to consider supporting. Our city would be better served with less negative publicity if complaints were filed locally and investigations were conducted at a faster pace.

  5. A major test of the ability of the private sector to solve problems with arrive in a week or two with the approval of the Pfizer vaccine. There is no organized plan from the federal government to distribute this vaccine in large quantities, and no plan for the payment, logistics or transportation/administration of the vaccine. Pfizer plans to use CVS and Walgreens to outsource the delivery and implementation of the first doses to nursing homes and hospitals. These vaccines have to be stored at -75 degrees celcius and administered by trained personnel (thousands of people will be needed and pharmacy technicians and pharmacists can’ t do it). My guess is that nothing is going to happen until Biden takes control of the government . Of course I don’t know for sure. But this is the type of operation that you really need the organizational, funding capacity of the federal government. The states alone can’t do it any more than they could do widespread testing.
    probably the best hospitals will be able to order , pay for, store and administer doses to their own staff members but the thousands of nursing homes in this country have no where near the capabilities.

  6. Where was Dennis Herrera – it’s his job to watch out for this, and to monitor contracts. For 20 years this was going on right under his nose. No clue. It took Donald Trumps appointee to flush this out – and rather quickly. The stench is horrible.

Comments are closed.

Sponsored link

Top reads

A new dark-money group with GOP support seeks to raise crime fears

A misleading mailer attacking the record of DA Chesa Boudin hits the streets—but who paid for it?

A car-free JFK Drive in Golden Gate Park is finally close to reality

But there are some complicated equity issues that will require a lot more discussion.

Robots in the crash pad: The twisted takeover of the Red Victorian Hotel

How Haight Ashbury countercultural ideals were distorted by a tech "co-living" experiment, and a trans performance community was displaced.

More by this author

A new dark-money group with GOP support seeks to raise crime fears

A misleading mailer attacking the record of DA Chesa Boudin hits the streets—but who paid for it?

While people sit in jail cells, SF courts delay criminal trials

Judges hear civil cases while violating the law and delaying the right to a speedy trial for criminal defendants, public defender says.

A car-free JFK Drive in Golden Gate Park is finally close to reality

But there are some complicated equity issues that will require a lot more discussion.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED