Sponsored link
Wednesday, November 29, 2023

Sponsored link

News + PoliticsCops use force on Black people 21 times as often as on...

Cops use force on Black people 21 times as often as on white people

Police Commission to discuss the issue. Plus: Corporate rentals and the mayor's power over Muni fares. That's The Agenda for Oct. 29-Nov. 5

-

The San Francisco Police Commission will discuss Wednesday/1 the astonishing racial inequality in the department’s use of force.

Data that the commission requested, based on information buried in an earlier report, shows that police in San Francisco use force against Black people 21 times as often as white people.

That figure has barely changed since 2016, the last time the use-of-force policy was updated.

The department, in a presentation prepared for the commission meeting, lists a variety of things that it’s trying to do to address the issue, including expanded stop data, diversity in recruitment efforts, and “educational civil rights tours for newly graduated recruits.”

Police data shows the radical racial discrepancy.

None of that seems to be making much of a difference.

Meanwhile, Mayor London Breed’s new proposals for the Police Department would make it even harder to track this sort of bias: She is asking that cops be freed from filling out as many forms and doing as many reports, so they can spend more time on the streets.

The mayor’s appointees have a 4-3 majority on the Police Commission, but some of them, particularly Max Carter-Oberstone, have pushed for a reform agenda and more transparency—and infuriated Breed in the process.

That meeting starts at 5pm.

I’m getting used to this, but it’s still a bit disturbing: On the Planning Commission’s Consent Calendar, which included matters that are “considered to be routine,” there are once again a bunch of conditional-use authorizations that would allow rental housing to be turned into “intermediate length occupancy” units.

ILOs are apartments that are rented out of more than 30 days but typically less than a year. They’re used, in some cases, by visiting artists and musicians who are, say, in town for three months for the run of a play, or are joining the symphony for a season. That’s all fine, and the supes have agreed that there’s a need for some—some—of this type of housing in the city.

But all too often, landlords take advantage of the system to create what are in effect corporate condos.

When the supes approved ILO housing, they required landlords to go before the Planning Commission to get a CU—meaning neighbors could come to a hearing and object.

But the commission never holds these hearings; instead, all of the ILO approvals are “routine.”

This week, seven: three on Van Ness, one on California, one on 18th Street.

Maybe they’re all legit. But every time the commission approves one, the city loses an apartment that could be rented to long-term residents. And since (despite new state laws that are very generous to developers) nobody is building right now, we are continuing to lose rental housing.

All without a single hearing or any investigation into what these units will ultimately become.

That hearing starts at noon.

The full Board of Supes is starting to consider measures for the March ballot, and while a charter amendment that would lock in funding for more cops is set to be continued until next week, a measure that would require mayoral approval for Muni fare hikes and increased parking meters is on the Tuesday/31 agenda.

Sups. Aaron Peskin and Ahsha Safai want more direct accountability for decisions now made by the director of the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency. That would force Breed, in this case, to say she supports longer hours of enforcement at parking meters and more meters in residential neighborhoods—something that small businesses and neighborhood groups all over the city tend to oppose. The mayor would also have to sign off on fare hikes—again, something that is almost always unpopular.

(When I moved to SF, the fare for Muni was 25 cents, although Mayor Dianne Feinstein was moving it to 50 cents. Adjusted for inflation, that would be 88 cents today. The current fare is $2.50.)

Sup. Matt Dorsey, an ally of the mayor, voted against the measure in committee, saying that he didn’t want to politicize Muni.

In fact, the mayor already appoints all the members of the SFMTA Board, and the director. But she can avoid responsibility for fare hikes and more parking meters by leaving it up to that agency.

It takes six votes to put a charter amendment before the voters. The supes full board meeting starts at 2pm.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our FacebookTwitter, and Instagram

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

Top reads

Housing bill that makes no sense at all moves forward with reluctant committee vote

Trickle-down economics from the Reagan Era rules as the state forces San Francisco to give luxury developers what they want (and ignores affordable housing).

Supes push back on state-mandated housing disaster

Plus: An honest discussion about the cops and budget priorities. That's The Agenda for Nov. 26 to Dec. 3

Screen Grabs: Sex, tech, and Godzilla—who could ask for anything more?

Three film fests bring the essentials. Plus: 'Pee Wee's Big Adventure' and more '80s delights

More by this author

On Giving Tuesday, please support the future of local news in San Francisco

Local newspapers are dying all over, threatening democracy. We are trying to keep community journalism alive. Can you help?

Housing bill that makes no sense at all moves forward with reluctant committee vote

Trickle-down economics from the Reagan Era rules as the state forces San Francisco to give luxury developers what they want (and ignores affordable housing).

Supes push back on state-mandated housing disaster

Plus: An honest discussion about the cops and budget priorities. That's The Agenda for Nov. 26 to Dec. 3
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED