Sponsored link
Wednesday, December 4, 2024

Sponsored link

City HallThe AgendaExpanding rent control, stopping the city from towing people's homes ....

Expanding rent control, stopping the city from towing people’s homes ….

... and what's up with Breed's School District strike force? That's The Agenda for Sept. 29 to Oct. 6

-

Close to 20,000 more apartments in San Francisco would come under rent control if Prop. 33 passes and the supes approve a bill that comes before the Land Use and Transportation Committee Monday/30.

The measure, by Sup. Aaron Peskin, would extend rent control to all housing units built between June 1979 and November 2024 if California voters approve Prop. 33 this fall.

If voters approve Prop. 33, San Francisco could see expanded rent control

Prop. 33 would overturn the Costa Hawkins Act, which bans rent control on any apartment built after 1979.

If Prop. 33 passes, rent control could once again become a central issue in San Francisco politics. Today, the state so limits what cities can do to limit rent hikes that it’s hard for the supes to do much beyond what already exists in local law.

The first step would be adding all the units that are now exempt. But Costa-Hawkins also bans rent controls on vacant apartments—and in the 1980s and early 1990s, that was a central issue in every local election. Supervisor and mayoral candidates who supported vacancy control—meaning the rent doesn’t rise to market levels whenever a tenant moves out—won the support of tenant groups. Those who didn’t were rejected by tenant groups. There wasn’t a lot of room for “moderates” to say they supported rent control but opposed the only form of rent control that really works to fight displacement.

Peskin has four co-sponsors, Sups. Dean Preston, Connie Chan, Hillary Ronen, and Shamann Walton. They need one more vote.

The landlords who are opposing Prop. 33 argue that tighter rent control discourages developers from building housing and thus drives up housing costs. Many of these same folks say that local oversight of land use in San Francisco has made housing unaffordable.

That doesn’t track with the data: Vancouver B.C. has rent control; it’s also seen massive new housing construction, tripling the housing stock in the last 30 years. So rent control didn’t stop developers. Oh, and  housing prices have not come down; they’re the highest in North America.

I’m sure we’ll hear the same arguments from some of the supes as this works its way to the full board. I hope Peskin and his allies challenge those statements with the reality of housing economics in 2024.

That meeting starts at 1:30 pm.

San Francisco is now moving aggressively to tow RVs where people, often families, are living on city streets. As El Tecolote reports, it’s not even clear that the approach is enforceable, and it’s certainly another level of cruelty in the mayor’s approach to homelessness.

But the SFMTA will be voting Tuesday/1 on a measure to ban overnight parking by almost anything resembling a trailer or RV almost everywhere in San Francisco and allowing the city to tow and essentially confiscate people’s homes.

Democratic Socialists of America will hold a rally at noon on the steps of City Hall, and the group is encouraging people to go to the meeting and give public comment against the plan. The meeting starts at 1pm in Room 400.

The San Francisco Unified School District is facing all kinds of problems, including the inability to fill special education positions that are required by state law, and the superintendent has delayed telling families which schools will close. (There’s not even much evidence that school closures will save the district significant money.)

The real issue, of course, is that California spends far too little money per student on public education (about half of what New York spends), leaving districts scrambling to provide basic services. That’s one of the results of Prop. 13.

Meanwhile, Mayor London Breed has allocated $8.4 million for a “School Stabilization Team” that includes Rec-Park Director Phil Ginsburg, who is best known for seeking to make money by privatizing the parks.

Rori Abernathy, who teaches seventh grade math in the district and is a California Teachers Association state delegate, told me the whole idea is a disaster. “It’s just another attack on us,” she said. “Haven’t we been attacked enough already?

“Teachers are talking about this and saying it’s beyond fake, it’s just going to cause chaos. Not one of us has been asked about this, and there’s no plan for asking us.”

The supes were a little dubious about it at the last meeting, and now Sups. Ahsha Safai and Aaron Peskin have called for a special hearing of the full board, as a Committee of the Whole, to discuss the situation Tuesday/1. That hearing is scheduled for 3pm.

48 Hills welcomes comments in the form of letters to the editor, which you can submit here. We also invite you to join the conversation on our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. 

Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.

Featured

Good Taste: Local gifts for the food-obsessed

Spread some delicious cheer with spices, jams, shared feasts, cookbooks, festive holiday markets, and more.

Money talks

An interview with the 'man of wealth and taste' who determined the outcome of most of the US elections this fall.

Special Deal! Get one month of ads FREE in 2025

Support local indie media and reach tens of thousands of readers—plus get one month free when you place 1+ month of ads.

More by this author

Newsom wants to challenge Trump—but he won’t address the biggest issue

If Trump starts cutting funding to the state and its local government, California will face massive problems—unless Newsom and the Democrats are willing to tax the rich.

The SF Zoo is a mess, new report shows

Supes to request full audit after study shows the facility is unsafe for its existing animals—and has no business hosting Mayor Breed's pandas.

Judge refuses new trial in Tenderloin shooting case where jurors say they wrongly convicted

Now it's up to the same judge to determine if Jhacorey Wyatt spends more time in jail, or goes home to his family.
Sponsored link
Sponsored link

You might also likeRELATED