Thursday, April 15, 2021
News + Politics Shocking police stats -- but where's the chief?

Shocking police stats — but where’s the chief?

Supes hear dramatic data about arrests and killings of Black and mentally ill people -- but still no accountability at any level of SFPD as Suhr ducks hearing


There were two fundamental problems with the supes hearing on police violence today: Chief Greg Suhr decided not to show up – and for all the talk of policy changes that the city might need to implement, there was little discussion of accountability.

Widely circulated video shows police shooting Mario Woods in the Bayview

How is it, Sup. David Campos asked, that the chief is able to make misleading, sometimes inaccurate statements to the public after shootings –claiming, for example, that the killing of Mario Woods was justified before even the earliest facts were in?

How is it that the officers who killed Woods, in what seems from the video to be a very dubious shooting, are still on the payroll? “That sends a horrible message,” Campos noted.

The behavior of the Police Officers Association also came up, with a number of public speakers saying they felt intimidated when a large crowd of officers marched into the Police Commission last night. “If 70 young black men had done that, we would have been tagged as a gang,” one person noted.

Sup. John Avalos argued that “it also looks as if the department is afraid of the POA.”

The numbers presented were alarming. San Francisco, Sup. Malia Cohen noted, has had 37 police shootings since 2012, and every one of them has been deemed justified.

Aaron Zisser, a police-practices expert who is a former US Justice Department official, said that people with mental illness are 4.5 times more likely to be arrested, and that, nationwide, between 15 and 25 percent of the jail population is mentally ill. “In some jurisdictions,” he testified, “fifty percent of all police shootings involve people with mental illness.”

Black men between the ages of 15 and 19 were 21 times more likely to be killed by the police than white men of the same age group between 20101 and 2013. African Americans are six percent of the population and 40 percent of those shot by the police.

He talked of the need for more “self-examination” in policing, saying that too much of modern law-enforcement is based on the “warrior model – the war on crime, the war on drugs.”

Surh, who typically attends these types of hearings, instead sent Greg Yee, the captain of the training division, who had lots of positive words about the way new recruits should be taught. “In the United Kingdom [where most cops don’t carry guns] the sanctity of life is primary,” he said. “We are seeing a shift in culture at the Police Academy.”

The director of the Office of Citizen Complaints, Joyce Hicks, echoed some of those comments and offered a list of policy suggestions.

Cohen suggested that, in the wake of the recent wave of officer shootings of young men of color, “It seems we’re being very reactive. The Mayor’s Office has been a little late to the party.”

And, she said, “people have reached the breaking point. That’s why they are stopping traffic”

None of the expert testimony addressed the issue of current officers, with current training, ignoring current rules, and escaping accountability.

As Avalos said at the end, “These are nice and kind words, but until we have a sense that there are consequences” for cops, there will be no real change.



Tim Redmond
Tim Redmond has been a political and investigative reporter in San Francisco for more than 30 years. He spent much of that time as executive editor of the Bay Guardian. He is the founder of 48hills.


  1. 1. Any properly trained individual could break a perps wrist in three places with a baton. Mario Woods was yet another gang killing.

    2. Mandatory random drug testing for anyone carrying, or that might use a firearm.

    3. Immediate drug testing in all officer-involved shootings.

    4. Better psychological screening of recruits, ESPECIALLY former military personnel (I’m convinced a lot of cops suffer some degree of PTSD).

    5. Require police officers to ive in the municipality they police.

    “Goon Squad Attempts To Intimidate Community:”

Comments are closed.

More by this author

Breed won’t promise to spend real-estate tax money on rent relief

The voters approved Prop. I last fall to support tenants and affordable housing, but the mayor says she will use the money for her own priorities.

Reese Erlich, foreign correspondent and radical reporter, is dead at 73

After a life of progressive politics, ground-breaking journalism, and social activism, a legendary writer loses battle with cancer.

There’s a lot more to the GG Park debate than cars v. bikes

This is part of a huge discussion the city needs to have about transportation -- and equity -- in a post-COVID world.

SF could have affordable Internet for everyone for $35 a resident

Why isn't the Breed Administration moving for municipal broadband? That's The Agenda for April 11-18

A new move to get corporate money out of state political campaigns

AB 20 would ban contributions from corporations to any candidate for state office in CA.

Most read

Radical right group is trying to attack public-sector labor in SF

Anti-union mailers are going to workers home addresses -- but really, this group is looking pretty desperate.

How To Reopen Nightlife: Enough with the boys’ club, make room for women

DJ femmelectric and promoter Alex McGeagh speak about equity, access, and safety for women and nonbinary folks.

Black Freighter Press sails in, boosting writers of color and radical imagination

The revolution will be published, with the help of SF Poet Laureate Tongo Eisen-Martin and Alie Jones' new outlet.

City College students fight back against brutal faculty cuts

Firing teachers could also mean the end of a lot of treasured programs.

You might also likeRELATED